Skip to main content

CoinDesk Crypto

First Mover: Bitcoin Miners Find Upgrade Financing Aplenty, Even as Prices Languish

6 years 2 months ago

Even as bitcoin prices languish below $10,000, North American cryptocurrency mining companies are tapping into a flurry of fresh financing from investors to pay for new equipment upgrades, bolstering the blockchain network’s resilience and reducing its reliance on Chinese operators.  

More than $1 billion of new bitcoin-mining computers will be purchased for North American bitcoin mining in the next two years, several people familiar with the industry told CoinDesk. That’s about five times the publicly traded mining-equipment maker Canaan’s revenue for all of 2019. 

You’re reading First Mover, CoinDesk’s daily markets newsletter. Assembled by the CoinDesk Markets Team, First Mover starts your day with the most up-to-date sentiment around crypto markets, which of course never close, putting in context every wild swing in bitcoin and more. We follow the money so you don’t have to. You can subscribe here.

Related: Blockchain Bites: Binance’s Bitcoin Mining, ConsenSys’ Legal Trouble and Why Politicians Blame Twitter, Not Bitcoin

“North America is not going to completely take over mining, but there is going to be growth,” Trevor Smyth, managing partner of San Francisco-based Arctos Capital, said in a phone interview. In April, Arctos funded a $1 million sale-and-leaseback transaction for Blockware Mining, a bitcoin mining and rig-hosting company, according to a press release at the time. 

The trend shows that entrepreneurs and investors are undaunted by the recent doldrums in the bitcoin market, where for the past month prices have remained stuck – almost uncannily quiet for the historically volatile cryptocurrency – in a range between roughly $9,000 and $10,000. It’s been a big disappointment for many bitcoin bulls, after a slew of predictions earlier this year that the May’s once-every-four-years “halving” might send prices to $90,000 or higher.

But the availability of financing for upgrades could put pressure on industry players to keep investing in new equipment, perpetuating the hardware arms race even without fresh price signals. It’s sort of like purchasing a new smartphone every year just to avoid falling behind the cutting edge. 

Dave Perrill, CEO of Compute North, a Minnesota-based data center operator that offers hosting services for bitcoin miners, estimates that at least 2 million new-generation mining rigs will be produced during the current hardware cycle, with at least 400,000 units landing in North America.

Related: Aave’s LEND Token Is Now Up 1,600% in 2020

“We believe that upwards of 20% of the new equipment will be operated there,” Perrill said. 

Blockfills, a Chicago-based cryptocurrency market maker, says it will provide equipment financing for North American bitcoin miners who can obtain power-purchase agreements and secure base facilities in the U.S. or Canada. 

“We expect to fund approximately $250 million ourselves in the next 12 months,” Neil Van Huis, director of sales and institutional trading at Blockfills, told First Mover in a phone interview.

Smyth, of Arctos Capital, said his firm is financing North American bitcoin mining equipment purchases in the range of $1 million to $2 million per deal. 

Investors looking to gain a yield in a low-interest economic environment are investing in bitcoin mining – more so than ever before, Smyth said. Lenders can earn an attractive return from the interest charged in the deals, known as commercial leasing, he said. 

“We raise capital through multiple sources,” Smyth said. “Ultimately they find our business is able to generate attractive risk-adjusted yields that can help diversify their investment portfolios.” 

The investment proposition has become even more enticing since the coronavirus-induced economic crisis led to a collapse in yields on everything from U.S. Treasury bonds to mortgages. Smyth says his investors are seeing “non-correlated, steady returns.”

Arctos gets debt capital from institutions like banks and securitization partners. There is also a private Regulation D fund, which has exemption from SEC registration for small firms like Arctos to raise capital, he said.

The investment push could also give North America a bigger share of the bitcoin mining industry, historically dominated by Chinese operators, many of them with ready access to cheap electricity from hydropower plants. Currently, China has 65% of the geographical mining market share. 

Smyth pointed to the entry into the bitcoin market of high-profile investors like Paul Tudor Jones III as a sign that more institutional capital is coming to crypto, despite the lack of price action.

The debt financing deals may be easier for many investors to understand than, say, taking a flyer on bitcoin perpetual derivatives on a Seychelles-based exchange. 

“There’s certainly going to be hedge funds coming in and directly holding bitcoin,” he said. “But I actually see more opportunity for the bitcoin industry to attract institutional investors through structured debt products such as lease financing.”

Smyth says he sees a continuation of the “survival of the fittest” dynamic in the industry, where only the most efficient operators can keep up with the Bitcoin blockchain’s ever-increasing computational power, known as the hash rate.

The halving, which occurred on May 12, was the latest such milestone for the bitcoin blockchain, as programmed into the network’s 11-year-old code. The number of bitcoin produced as the reward for mining a new data block – roughly every 10 minutes – dropped to 6.25 from 12.5. 

Ahead of the event, miners scrambled to upgrade their equipment to avoid becoming obsolete. And the amount of power used in bitcoin mining subsequently declined 43% in late May, according to the Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, in what might be an indication of the efficiency gains from the new generation of machines. 

The hash rate is currently around 120 million terahashes per second, close to record highs. And that has caused a self-regulating mechanism coded into the Bitcoin blockchain, a factor known as “mining difficulty,” to hit new highs as new, more efficient machines are put into service. 

It’s another force pushing miners to continue upgrading. More record difficulty highs are likely to accompany the deployment of new machines like the Bitmain S19 Pro and MicroBT M30S++, unveiled earlier this year. 

“Miners that are more efficient and stay online actually earn more bitcoin,” Smyth said. “It’s self-adjusting.”  

Tweet of the day Bitcoin watch

BTC: Price: $9,160 (BPI) | 24-Hr High: $9,235 | 24-Hr Low: $9,119

Trend: Bitcoin is again sidelined near $9,160, having witnessed a trading range of just $325 last week – the lowest since the last week of March 2019. 

As a result, bitcoin’s Bollinger bands, volatility indicators placed two standard deviations above and below the 20-day moving average, are now even more compressed than they were last week. “Such behavior could be considered a sign that a period of high volatility is just around the corner,” said Konstantin Anissimov, executive director at the cryptocurrency exchange CEX.IO. 

Indeed a prolonged period of low-volatility trading often ends up with a big move in either direction. The analyst community has been calling a spike in volatility for more than two weeks now. So far, however, both buyers and sellers have refrained from making big bets on the cryptocurrency, leaving prices directionless above $9,000.

Should the long-held psychological support of $9,000 cave in, stronger chart-driven selling pressure may likely emerge, pushing the cryptocurrency down to the 50-week moving average at $8,550.

Alternatively, a move above $9,480 would invalidate a bearish lower high created on July 8 and expose resistance at $9,800 (June 22 high) and $10,000. 

Related Stories
CoinDesk

Bitcoin Futures Trading Volume Slips to 3-Month Low on CME

6 years 2 months ago

Trading activity in bitcoin futures listed on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) has cooled notably as the leading cryptocurrency languishes in the price doldrums.

Daily trading volume fell to $87 million (via 1,895 contracts) on Friday to hit the lowest level since April 17, when the exchange-traded contracts were worth $77 million, according to data from crypto derivatives research firm Skew. 

Volume topped out at $914 million on May 11 – the day bitcoin underwent its third miner reward halving – and has been on a declining trend ever since.

Related: Crypto Long & Short: Why the Twitter Hack Was Good for Bitcoin (and It’s Not the Media Attention)

The halving was widely expected to put a strong bid under the cryptocurrency. Instead, bitcoin’s uptrend from March lows below $4,000 stalled following the halving, and the cryptocurrency has remained largely locked in the range of $9,000 to $10,000 ever since.

The unusually quiet period for bitcoin trading seems to be the primary reason behind the steady decline in CME’s futures volume. 

Global daily volume, as calculated by adding numbers from BitMEX, Deribit, Kraken, OKEx, bitFlyer, CoinFlex, CME. Huobi, FTX, Bitfinex, Binance, Bybit, and Bakkt, has also tanked over the past two months.  

As of Sunday, aggregate daily volume was just $4.65 billion – down 87% from the $36 billion observed on May 11. 

Related: The Origins of the World’s Oldest Bitcoin Metric, Explained

“Continued range-trading and an inability to confidently break above $10,000 has led investors to allocate capital into other segments of the crypto market,” said Matthew Dibb, co-founder of Stack, a provider of cryptocurrency trackers and index funds. 

Also read: DeFi Driving Chainlink’s Link Token to Record Highs

Indeed, alternative cryptocurrencies like the oracle network Chainlink’s LINK token, Stellar’s XLM and tokens associated with the decentralized finance (DeFi) space like Compound’s LEND have received greater attention from the investor community over the past week or two. 

Tokens like LINK and XLM have witnessed a surge in trading volumes in the spot market this month, while bitcoin’s volume in both the spot market and futures market has declined. 

LINK’s trading volume on Coinbase, the largest U.S. exchange, has increased by 67%, while XLM’s volume has jumped by nearly 40% to new record highs. Meanwhile, bitcoin trading has diminished for the third straight month. 

“With the hype around the DeFi, this trend may continue for the short-term,” Dibb said in a direct chat with CoinDesk. 

CME open interest down too

Open interest, or open positions in futures, listed on the CME (which is considered synonymous with institutional participation) has also declined along with the daily trading volume. As of Friday, $364 million worth of positions were open on the CME – down 31% from the high of $532 million observed on May 19. 

However, aggregate or global open interest remains elevated near $4 billion, the highest level since early March. 

Derivative analysts consider the combination of declining trading volume and elevated open interest as a sign of investors holding on to their positions. In such cases, markets usually extend the preceding move, meaning bitcoin could break above $10,000 in the near-term, marking a continuation of the uptrend from the March low of $3,867. 

Disclosure: The author holds no cryptocurrency at the time of writing.

Related Stories
CoinDesk

Bank of Japan Forms New Team to Explore Central Bank Digital Currency

6 years 2 months ago

The Bank of Japan (BOJ) has set up a dedicated team to explore the implications of central bank digital currencies.

  • As reported by Reuters on Monday, the central bank is warming up to the possibility of a digital yen, given the recent rise in interest among other central banks.
  • While details are limited, the new team will likely follow up on the BOJ’s 2019 research into central bank digital currencies (CBDCs), as well as the additional research it has been conducting with other central banks since January.
  • The team will form part of the central bank’s payment and settlement department.
  • Deputy governor Masayoshi Amamiya previously said that it would be hard for central banks to make negative interest rate policies more effective through the issuance of their own digital currencies.
  • He reasoned that it would force individuals and businesses to pay to hold a CBDC and, as such, would motivate people to not use the digital form of money.
  • But the BOJ is shifting its thinking on the technology as regional rival China’s digital currency enters testing with commercial entities.
  • Japan’s government is set to examine the possible launch of a digital yen as part of this year’s policy agenda, per a report last week.

Also read: Bank of England Considering a Central Bank Digital Currency, Governor Says

Related Stories
CoinDesk

Mastercard Now Allows Crypto Firm Wirex to Issue Payment Cards

6 years 2 months ago

One of the world’s largest payments processor said Wirex was the first native crypto company to be able to directly issue payment cards to its customers.

  • As part of an expansion of its cryptocurrency program, Mastercard said Monday it had granted Wirex principal membership status.
  • Regulated by the U.K.’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Wirex offers a payment facility that automatically exchanges crypto into fiat currencies.
  • Wirex’s original card had been with rival Visa; the company will now be able to use Mastercard’s network for fiat currency payments.
  • Mastercard processed more than $1.6 trillion in Q1 2020; an 8% increase year-on-year.
  • Raj Dhamodharan, Mastercard’s executive vice president on digital assets and blockchain, said the company wanted to work within a maturing cryptocurrency industry.
  • Mastercard also said it had made its processes easier for other crypto companies to become principal members as well as access some of its acceleration programs.

See also: BitPay Launches Prepaid Crypto Mastercard for US Customers

Related Stories
CoinDesk

Canada Crypto Exchange Coinsquare Accused of Wash Trading by Watchdog

6 years 2 months ago

Canada-based crypto trading platform Coinsquare has been accused by the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) of inflating its trading volumes in an illegal practice called wash trading.

  • In a Statement of Allegations from the OSC, filed last Thursday, the regulator alleges Coinsquare’s CEO Cole Diamond, founder Virgile Rostand and executive Felix Mazer knowingly manipulated markets via fake trading volumes and “authorized, permitted or acquiesced in this conduct” by the firm’s staff.
  • Staff were directed by Diamond to engage in wash trading activity, while Rostand designed and implemented the code to carry out the activity, the statement alleges.
  • Mazer was made Coinsquare’s chief compliance officer (CCO) from May 2018 until June 2020, but he “failed to take steps that a reasonable CCO would have taken,” the commission said.
  • The regulator said fake trades represented 90% of Coinsquare’s reported volume between July 2018 and December 2019.
  • It also alleges that between July 17, 2018 and December 4, 2019, approximately 840,000 wash trades were conducted on the platform with an aggregate value of around 590,000 bitcoin (worth over $5.4 billion at press time).
  • When a Coinsquare whistleblower repeatedly sought to expose the illicit activities, the company carried out reprisals against them, the OSC claims.
  • The alleged misconduct also occurred while Coinsquare was applying to the OSC to register a subsidiary, Coinsquare Capital Markets Ltd. In the process, the platform concealed these activities from OSC staff.
  • The OSC statement came after a report by Motherboard, Vice Magazine’s tech section, last month saying Coinsquare had engaged in wash trading.
  • It based the report on leaked emails, Slack messages and other sources of information.
  • The OSC Secretary will now hold a hearing to determine whether it is in the public interest to approve a settlement agreement between the OSC and Coinsquare.
  • The hearing will be held on July 21, 2020, at 19:30 UTC.

See also: Canada’s Financial Crimes Watchdog Gets Ready for FATF Compliance

Related Stories
CoinDesk

Wanted Wirecard Exec Said to Be Sheltered by Secret Service in Russia

6 years 2 months ago

A former board member of Wirecard, sought by authorities over the company’s missing $2.1 billion, has reportedly surfaced in Russia.

  • According to a report in German new source Handelsblatt on Sunday, Jan Marsalek is now staying in a property in the west of Moscow under the supervision of Russia’s largest secret service, the military controlled GRU.
  • Handelsblatt cited judges, diplomat and business people as the source of the information.
  • Marsalek is also said to have sent large amounts of bitcoin to Russia from Dubai, where Wirecard had operated “dubious” services.
  • Another German news source, Der Spiegel, also reported over the weekend that Marsalek had originally flown to Belarus.
  • Tense political relations between Russia and Belarus’ leader reportedly meant the GRU felt it would be better to bring the fugitive to Russia.
  • Handelsblatt suggests there may be a previous link between the Austrian Wirecard board member and the GRU, and that Marsalek had styled himself as a secret agent.
  • In mid June, Wirecard – which supplied cards to cryptocurrency firms Crypto.com and TenX – said a quarter of its total balance sheet was absent after “spurious cash balances” were provided to its auditor, EY.
  • Days later, Crypto.com told CoinDesk it would refund customers after U.K. told Wirecard’s card issuing subsidiary to cease operations. That ban was lifted on June 30 and the firm was able to continue card services.
  • EY has seen criticism over its failure to spot the massive hole in Wirecard’s books.
Related Stories
CoinDesk

PayPal Picks Paxos to Supply Crypto for New Service, Sources Say

6 years 2 months ago

PayPal, the fintech giant planning to bring crypto trading to its massive user base, has chosen Paxos to handle the new service’s supply of digital assets, according to two people familiar with the matter.

It’s a plum assignment for New York-based Paxos, which last week launched Paxos Crypto Brokerage and announced its first customer in Revolut US, the American division of the U.K.-based fintech firm that offers bitcoin trading. A formal announcement of the PayPal relationship could come as soon as this week, one source said.

The offering would make PayPal one of the most prominent mainstream companies to offer cryptocurrency purchases, joining fellow publicly-traded payments provider Square and unicorn stock brokerage Robinhood.

Related: UK Fintech Firm Revolut Brings Bitcoin, Ether Trading to US Customers

It is not clear exactly which cryptocurrencies PayPal intends to offer. Paxos declined to comment for this story. PayPal did not return requests for comment by press time. CoinDesk broke the news of PayPal’s crypto plans on June 22. 

Read more: PayPal, Venmo to Roll Out Crypto Buying and Selling: Sources

CoinDesk reported then that PayPal and its Venmo subsidiary would be bringing direct buying and selling of crypto to some portion of the company’s 325 million users.

The new Paxos brokerage, an API-based solution for making crypto services easy for businesses to roll out, allows cryptocurrency buying, selling, holding and sending capabilities – while handling all regulatory compliance aspects. Paxos, which holds a New York state trust charter, is a qualified custodian, legally permitted to hold gold and digital assets such as bitcoin (BTC) and ether (ETH) on institutional investors’ behalf. 

Related: Jack Dorsey’s Cash App Sponsors NASCAR Driver Bubba Wallace

San Francisco-based cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase, which has a longstanding relationship with PayPal, was said to be in line to provide some kind of white-labeled crypto offering. European exchange Bitstamp (which provides crypto liquidity to Revolut in the U.K.) was also mentioned as a contender at the time. Both companies declined to comment for this story.

PayPal playing catchup

The crypto wings of traditional fintech apps are steadily growing in stature.

Crypto is steadily moving from being a pseudo-asset with fringe appeal to becoming a must-have for fintech and challenger-bank apps looking to build revenue and customers.

In addition to Revolut entering the U.S. market with crypto trading, Square, the payments unicorn launched by Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey, has seen its bitcoin trading revenues grow. Square rolled out bitcoin purchases in its Cash App in mid-2018 and reported $306 million in bitcoin revenue in its most recent earnings report.

Read more: PayPal Told EU It Had Crypto Plans Back in March

Meanwhile, Robinhood, the fintech app favored by a new generation of day traders, first offered crypto in February 2018. (Robinhood had over 2 million downloads in the quarter it released Robinhood Crypto, the firm’s highest count ever.)

In a blog post published last week, Paxos CEO Charles Cascarilla said his firm’s new brokerage service could be a “tipping point” for cryptocurrency, suggesting more clients were on the way, “from fintech apps to banks to brokers to e-commerce brands.” In an interview with The Block, Cascarilla said Paxos is prepared to scale its own internal exchange, itBit, to meet the demands of new clients.

Related Stories
CoinDesk

Novel Charts Dark Side of ICO Mania

6 years 2 months ago

The initial coin offering boom of 2017 and 2018 was the closest crypto came to mass adoption.

It was a period of market and media exuberance. The Gray Lady, aka the New York Times, perhaps looking to court the new taste-makers and the hilariously wealthy, published think pieces about the crypto revolution and the leaders behind it. 

About 1,000 different token projects raised over $22 billion over two years, according to CoinDesk Research. To put it in perspective, that’s approximately half the gross domestic product of Tuvalu, the country with the smallest GDP at that time. Unlike the natural resources and domain names this tiny Pacific island nation cashes in on, the majority of token projects turned out to be vaporware. 

Related: The Novel Legal Strategy Bringing This ICO-Backed ‘Micro-Mobility’ Startup to Court

Many petered out unremembered. Some were straight-up scams. A few became household names, (for the wrong reasons). 

Haydn Wilks, a Welsh author, has memorialized the era in his second novel, “$hitcoin,” published this month by Dead Bird Press. It’s a story of grift and determination, about the revolutionary potentials of distributed technology and how fortunes were made and lost in an instant.

We caught up with the 32-year-old Wilks to discuss his work, his experiences during the ICO boom and the latest in crypto. 

In the novel, you walk the line between celebrating the potential technological benefits of crypto and also showing how some ICOs were get-rich schemes. Where do you find your own thoughts on the matter: Is crypto revolutionary, or is it a story people are trying to sell?

Related: To His Own Surprise, Crypto Volume Pumper’s Business Is Still Thriving

I think that there are elements of both sides that are true. A lot of the tech was and is truly ground-breaking, cutting-edge stuff. But there were also a lot of ICOs launched purely with the intention of making as much [money] as possible as quickly as possible. And it was often very hard to distinguish between them.

OysterPearl is one project that’s mentioned briefly in the novel – that was based on a unique idea that many saw real potential in, using visitors to a website’s computing power for storage as an alternative to serving advertising to generate money for the website. But the founder of Oyster Pearl was completely anonymous and even those working for the project didn’t know his real identity. The guy behind it built a vulnerability into the Oyster Pearl smart contract that allowed him to produce a load of new coins, sell them and disappear into anonymity while the project collapsed.

When did you come into crypto or become aware of it? If you’re still following the developments, does anything strike you for its artistic potential? 

I was aware of Bitcoin for years before I really got into it. I’m not sure of the exact date, but maybe in 2012 or 2013 I tried to get into it, but it was a lot more difficult to get started in those days. I remember trying to download a copy of the blockchain to my PC, thinking that was the only way to set up a Bitcoin wallet! By 2017, you had much more user-friendly ways of buying cryptocurrency with fiat currency.

Freelance writing work around the crypto space became more difficult to find as the 2017 hype died away. By 2019, most of the sites I’d worked for had become unprofitable and were no longer commissioning new articles, so I’ve not been keeping up with new developments in the space as closely as I was in the past. But I think the big projects like Ethereum have continued becoming more and more integrated into the tech and finance mainstream so I’m sure that there are a lot of interesting new stories to be told.

See also: As Museums Go Dark, Crypto Art Finds Its Frame

Who do you think are the most interesting real-life characters in crypto today? 

The crypto scene is full of larger-than-life characters! Some of the most interesting for a variety of different reasons would be Vitalik Buterin, Justin Sun, Craig S. Wright, C.Z. from Binance – the list goes on and on. The stories I found the most interesting were the ones with a lot of human drama to them. The split between Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin Cash Satoshi’s Vision would make a great movie. Another story I found really fascinating was the rise of Binance and how they had to move around different countries, growing exponentially the whole time, until they could find a permanent base. 

There’s a huge amount of real-life drama to draw on in this world and I definitely think this won’t be the last work of fiction on the topic.

Do you think the cultural experience of the ICO days was different in Europe and the U.S.? Was it a global experience?

I mainly saw it from an Asian perspective as I was living in [South] Korea at the time. When I returned to the U.K. during 2017, it seemed like most people were aware of cryptocurrency, but there wasn’t the same appetite to invest in it that I saw in Korea. I was teaching at a university in Korea and students would talk about cryptocurrency in class quite regularly. You would also hear people talking about it everywhere you went, like bars, restaurants and cafes. I think something like 50% of Korean twentysomethings were investing in cryptocurrency, which must have been a much higher percentage than in Europe and the United States.

Having said that, some of the most interesting stories came from Europe and the United States. RaiBlocks (later rebranded as Nano) was the coin I had most success with during the 2017 bull run – I bought it when it was only available on Mercatox and BitGrail and it was just 65 cents a coin. Within about a month, it was at over $30. And then it emerged that BitGrail had lost a huge amount of users tokens – hundreds of millions of dollars worth, depending on when you calculate the loss. And BitGrail was handling all this money while being run by one inexperienced programmer in Italy who hadn’t even registered the exchange as a limited company, leaving him personally liable for all its losses.

See also: Discovery Science to Premier Crypto-Funded TV Series About… Dragonchain?

Another project that fascinated me was Elixir – they generated quite a lot of hype at a time when almost every coin had big supporters saying what a great investment a project was on sites like Bitcoin Talk and Reddit. But if you visited their website, they hadn’t produced a full-length white paper. All they had was a two-page pamphlet. And the only credentials its founders seemed to have was a degree from the University of Iowa. Future Synergy Coin’s creators in the novel are in no way based on the team behind Elixir, but the fact that two students could create something with that much impact was definitely a big early inspiration for basing the novel on a group of frat bros launching their own ICO.

You are one of the first to write a crypto novel. How do you think the crypto phenomenon will fit in with the larger literary or cultural scenes?

It took me a long time to write this novel. I was quite frustrated with myself for how long it was taking, as I thought someone would surely beat me to it and get a movie or book on this phenomenon out before I did. I’m kind of pleasantly surprised that this is the first novel to really capture the ICO phenomenon. There’s a huge amount of real-life drama to draw on in this world and I definitely think this won’t be the last work of fiction on the topic. Just as I was getting ready to launch the book, news broke that a movie is being produced based on “Bitcoin Billionaires,” a book about the Winklevoss twins’ involvement in Bitcoin. So I think that we are just starting to scratch the surface when it comes to this topic and there will be a lot more to come.

Related Stories
CoinDesk

Third Centra Tech Founder Pleads Guilty to ICO Fraud

6 years 2 months ago

U.S. prosecutors have secured a guilty plea from Sohrab Sharma, a co-founder of the Centra Tech initial coin offering (ICO) fraud.

  • As per the Friday plea, Sharma, 29, admitted that he and partners Raymond Trapani and Robert Farkas lied about their purportedly crypto-backed financial product’s partnerships, licenses and leadership as it ripped off investors for $25 million. He also forfeited 10,000 in ethereum ($2,329,200).
  • The trio touted celebrity endorsements and flashy investor promises while promoting their partnership at the height of the 2017 ICO bubble. But their apparent success and big-name claims quickly caught investigators’ attention, and before long they faced a bevy of legal actions from regulators and investors alike.
  • Sharma pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit securities fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit mail fraud.
  • Farkas pleaded guilty in June, while Trapani did the same last year.
Related Stories
CoinDesk

Market Wrap: Derivatives, Altcoins Take Market Spotlight as Bitcoin Dozes at $9,100

6 years 2 months ago

Traders want a bitcoin price breakout but they aren’t sure when that will happen.

  • Bitcoin (BTC) trading around $9,174 as of 20:00 UTC (4 p.m. ET). Gaining 0.64% over the previous 24 hours.
  • Bitcoin’s 24-hour range: $9,054-9,184
  • BTC above 10-day and 50-day moving average, a bullish signal for market technicians.

Read More: Exchanges See Drop in Volumes as Bitcoin Volatility Approaches 2020 Low

Traders are optimistic that bitcoin’s weak market, with low volumes and low volatility, can quickly change. Price movement outside of the low $9,000s territory is key, said Rupert Douglas, head of business development and institutional sales at London brokerage Koine. “This tussle between bulls and bears from $9,000 to $9,500 is a slow grind at the moment. A close outside these boundaries will likely see a sharp move either way.” 

Related: First Mover: Why Bitcoin Traders Couldn’t Give a Sat About the Twitter Hack

It will take more exciting news than a Twitter hack attempting to scam social media users out of bitcoin to bring the world’s oldest cryptocurrency out of stagnation, said Jean-Baptiste Pavageau, a partner at Paris-based quantitative trading firm ExoAlpha. 

Read More: Why Bitcoin Traders Couldn’t Give a Sat About the Twitter Hack

“The fact that bitcoin didn’t move because of the Twitter scam shows the importance of $9,100-$9,200 range to either consolidate the trend and move higher or invalidate the level and fall toward $8,200,” said Pavageau. 

In a sleepy bitcoin sector, several analysts pointed to the crypto derivatives market as a sign the industry is still growing. “In general, the markets have come a long way and I am particularly excited about some of the new derivatives platforms that have emerged.” Mick Sherman, founder of New York-based Trading Firm Altcoin Advisors. 

Related: Market Wrap: What Twitter Hack? Traders Stay Busy Buying Bitcoin at $9,000

In particular, CME, Binance and ByBit have seen growth in open interest.

In addition, U.S. dollar-denominated open interest on Seychelles-based derivatives exchange BitMEX is around $700 million, a high not seen since the excitement surrounding May 12’s bitcoin halving, a scheduled reduction in the cryptocurrency’s new supply output that happens roughly every four years. 

Read More: Bitcoin Halving 2020 Explained

“We still see a lot of interest and building momentum for derivatives and expect this to continue for some time, particularly as traditional managers seem less interested in holding the underlying but still want exposure to price movement,” said Douglas Bilyk, business development director at crypto brokerage Copper. 

Derivatives might be a factor, but cryptocurrencies other than bitcoin could weigh on the market as well, Bilyk added. “We’re expecting a large bitcoin move but direction is unclear. One ‘canary in the coal mine’ might be the bullish moves in some of the blockchain development tokens these past few weeks.” 

Ethereum transactions highest since 2018

The second-largest cryptocurrency by market capitalization, ether (ETH), was up Friday, trading around $233 and climbing 0.33% in 24 hours as of 20:00 UTC (4:00 p.m. EDT). 

This week, the Ethereum network experienced the most transactions in over two and a half years. On Monday, total transactions reached 1,151,834, the first time it has been that high since Jan. 18, 2018, according to data from aggregator Etherscan. 

With decentralized exchanges now around $60 million in volume per day, tokens on the Ethereum network, often referred to as altcoins, are giving traders new ideas to profit within the cryptocurrency ecosystem. “I don’t see bitcoin as a clear trading opportunity right now, however there are some opportunities with altcoins that have performed really well lately.” said Alessandro Andreotti, an Italy-based bitcoin over-the-counter trader.

Read More: Crypto Custodian Curv Is Helping Institutions Dabble in DeFi 

Other markets

Digital assets on the CoinDesk 20 are mostly in the red Friday. Notable winners as of 20:00 UTC (4:00 p.m. ET): 

Read More: Aave’s LEND Token Is Now Up 1,600% in 2020

Notable losers as of 20:00 UTC (4:00 p.m. ET): 

Read More: ConsenSys Accused of Stealing Payment Startup’s Code for Rival Service

Equities:

Read More: CoinDesk Quarterly Review, Q2 2020

Commodities: 

  • Oil is down 0.23%. Price per barrel of West Texas Intermediate crude: $40.59
  • Gold is up 0.76% Friday at $1,810 per ounce 

Read More: Binance Pool Poised to Grab More Bitcoin Hashrate in Russia and Asia

Treasurys:

  • U.S. Treasury bonds all climbed Friday. Yields, which move in the opposite direction as price, were up most on the two-year bond, in the green 5.7%.

Read More: BlockFi Hires Former Deutsche Bank, Barclays Alum as General Counsel

Related Stories
CoinDesk

Colorado Is Betting on ETHDenver and Web 3 for Its Next Lottery Games

6 years 2 months ago

The Colorado Lottery is partnering with ETHDenver, Ethereum’s largest hackathon, to spur the slapdash development of a decentralized web-based game of chance. 

  • The pair are calling on developers to compete in their July 31 “GameJam” hackathon that aims to build Web 3.0 novelties for the state-run lottery. Winners could ultimately see their finished projects premiere in Colorado bars and restaurants. First place will net a $10,000 payout.
  • Developers will get a goal (build a chance-based game), a deadline (nine days), a suggestion (make it decentralized web-friendly) and not much else, said John Paller, who runs ETHDenver. “We’ve intentionally not put huge rails on this,” he said. “We didn’t want to stifle creativity.”
  • Paller said that premiering winners’ games on decentralized infrastructure (an Ethereum-based game, say) is “on the table.” But he cautioned that “full Web 3.0 would be a Phase 2 thing” that depends on winners’ tech specs and ongoing discussions with the state.
  • Colorado is betting this jam will yield novel lottery products with broad gamer appeal, said Meghan Dougherty, communications director for the Colorado Lottery. “The lottery is really looking to grow into a billion-dollar organization by 2023, so we’re really trying to reimagine our game offerings,” she told CoinDesk. 
  • More lottery revenue equals more funding for state parks and schools – $13.7 million went to Colorado Parks and Wildlife last fiscal year. 
  • The pair are shooting for 200 registrants and at least 15 final submissions to yield three winners that could turn into lottery games, according to Paller.
Related Stories
CoinDesk

Twitter Hacker Is Mixing Bitcoin Loot Using a Wasabi Wallet, Elliptic Says

6 years 2 months ago

Funds collected by the scam that breached Twitter this week appear to be on the move, cryptocurrency tracing firm Elliptic said. 

According to transaction data associated with crypto wallets used in the security breach, a total of about $123,000 was collected by the attackers. Of that about 22%, 2.89 BTC, was transferred late last night to an address Elliptic said it “strongly believe(s)” is a Wasabi wallet.  

  • Wasabi wallets allow users to circumvent the transparency guaranteed by bitcoin’s public blockchain by mixing up the transaction trail thus making it harder for law enforcement to follow the money.
  • According to Elliptic, the firm is able to identify Wasabi wallets based on distinctive transaction patterns.While exchanges can usually identify their clients using KYC checks, which makes it possible to flag fraudsters for law enforcement, the use of a Wasabi wallet makes it harder to pin down where a client’s money came from. 
  • In a recent statement, Twitter said Wednesday’s security breach had targeted over 130 users, allowing attackers to gain control of user accounts and post identical messages demanding bitcoin. The firm also said it was investigating whether the attackers had accessed any non-public data on the platform. 
Related Stories
CoinDesk

Malaysia Crackdown Unlikely to Affect Binance, eToro

6 years 2 months ago

Malaysia’s financial watchdog says Binance and eToro don’t comply with the country’s securities law; it’s unlikely to make much of a difference to their local  operations, however. 

  • The Malaysian Securities Commission (SC) added exchanges Binance and eToro, which offer a series of crypto-based products, to a list of companies not permitted to operate in the country.
  • The regulator blacklists companies that offer financial services without its approval or authorization. 
  • It’s not clear when the SC added Binance and eToro to its non grata list. An official told CoinDesk that this information was not readily available.
  • Binance tested its newly launched debit card in Malaysia. The country’s currency, the ringgit, has been supported in Binance’s  peer-to-peer platform since March.
  • In May, the SC told local media that eToro was not authorized to operate in the country and was liable for a $2.4 million fine. 
  • Being blacklisted by the SC, however, is unlikely to disrupt either Binance’s or eToro’s local operations.
  • The SC does not have the authority to block websites – that rests with the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC), which so far has said nothing on the matter. 
  • An eToro spokesperson told CoinDesk the company’s Asian operations are all regulated by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission; Malaysian clients are effectively onboarded on an entity that falls out of the SC’s jurisdiction. 
  • Binance has resisted calls to publicly divulge where it’s headquartered. 
  • Bobby Ong, COO of price aggregator CoinGecko, which is based in Malaysia, said the SC may have fired a warning shot as Binance did not get the proper licenses before it started offering a ringgit gateway for its peer-to-peer marketplace.
  • Binance is one of the most high profile exchanges, but Ong said there were many other unregulated p2p ones operating in Malaysia. 
  • Binance did not respond to numerous requests for comment. 
Related Stories
CoinDesk

The DOJ Wants to Hire a Crypto Crime Attorney Adviser

6 years 2 months ago

The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) is looking to hire a dark web, cryptocurrency and computer hacking attorney adviser to assist in its crackdown on international cybercrime.

  • This 12-month position will build out DOJ’s crypto tracing and blockchain analysis capabilities, according to a Thursday job listing by the Criminal Division’s overseas development office.
  • Asia Pacific, Eastern Europe and Central Asia – regions DOJ said are rife with “sophisticated transnational organized crime threats” in the cybercrime and intellectual property underworld – will be a top focus for the adviser, according to the posting.
  • Applicants must attain or maintain a Top Secret security clearance as they work alongside DOJ’s Computer Crime and Intellectual Property Section and the U.S. Transnational and High-Tech Crime Global Law Enforcement Network, according to the posting.
Related Stories
CoinDesk

Blockchain Bites: Binance’s Bitcoin Mining, ConsenSys’ Legal Trouble and Why Politicians Blame Twitter, Not Bitcoin

6 years 2 months ago

In the aftermath of the Twitter hack, lawmakers are targeting lax cybersecurity, not Bitcoin.

Binance is looking to consolidate bitcoin mining in Russia, ConsenSys is being accused of stealing intellectual property and a celebrated comic book artist will be hawking his wares on the Ethereum blockchain.

You’re reading Blockchain Bites, the daily roundup of the most pivotal stories in blockchain and crypto news, and why they’re significant. You can subscribe to this and all of CoinDesk’s newsletters here. 

Top shelf

Related: Twitter Doesn’t Need Web 3.0 to Solve Its Identity Problem

Mining Consolidation
Binance is looking to consolidate more bitcoin mining hashrate to its pool in Russia and the Central Asia region. The world’s largest crypto exchange is deploying a physical server node for its pool at BitRiver, the largest bitcoin mining hosting provider in Bratsk, Russia. The move would give miner owners at BitRiver who choose to switch to Binance a better connection and direct route to its mining pool, the two firms said in an announcement Friday. In return, Binance would gain exposure and access to customers who run their machines at BitRiver, which currently operates mining facilities at a capacity of 70 megawatt (MW) out of potential capacity of 100 MW.

ConsenSys Accused
In a new lawsuit, Ethereum incubator ConsenSys is accused of abusing its position of trust as an investor to access trade secrets and create a rival offering. BlockCrushr, a payments app, said it received a $100,000 investment from ConsenSys and had 20 in-depth discussions with the incubator. Now, the startup says its intellectual property was misappropriated to build ConsenSys’s own payments system Daisy Payments, since rebranded to CodeFi. Plaintiffs filed two counts of misappropriating trade secrets and one count of a breach of contract, and are suing for damages.

CBDC in Action
A senior figure at the Bank of Thailand has confirmed it is already using a central bank digital currency (CBDC) for transactions with some businesses. Vachira Arromdee, the central bank’s assistant governor, told reporters Wednesday the bank plans to expand the use of the digital currency among large businesses, The Nation reported. It’s unclear what businesses are already using the digital currency; transactions with the Hong Kong Monetary Authority will be conducted with the CBDC from September, Arromdee confirmed.

Blockchain Blueprint
Beijing released a blueprint for its plans to become a blockchain hub by 2022. The 145-page details 12 potential areas for blockchain implementation, including airports, customs and small businesses, Decrypt reports. The municipal government also aims to create a fund dedicated to supporting local blockchain startups. The Block reports, “140 government services already use blockchain applications, which include data sharing, collaborative business management, and electronic certifications.”

Related: First Mover: Why Bitcoin Traders Couldn’t Give a Sat About the Twitter Hack

We’re All Comics in Crypto
Noted comic book illustrator Jose Delbo is releasing limited-edition art on MakersPlace, a blockchain-powered market for rare and collectible digital art, later this month. The listing includes 250 copies of a digital comic book and a one-of-a-kind digital Superman artwork by Delbo. MakersPlace uses Ethereum to verify the artworks and provide a digital signature from Delbo, who is also hosting a chat in Decentraland. 

Quick bites It’s Twitter, not Bitcoin

n the aftermath of the Twitter hack, lawmakers are blaming lax cybersecurity, not Bitcoin. Following the hack, which Twitter says affected 130 accounts, Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.), vocal critic of tech platforms, fired off an open letter to CEO Jack Dorsey. 

The event, Hawley said, “may represent not merely a coordinated set of separate hacking incidents but rather a successful attack on the security of Twitter itself.”

Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) also took aim at Twitter’s architecture. In a statement, he sounded off on the fact that users’ direct messages (DMs) lack end-to-end encryption. 

“This is a vulnerability that has lasted for far too long, and one that is not present in other, competing platforms. If hackers gained access to users’ DMs, this breach could have a breathtaking impact for years to come,” Wyden said. Wyden revealed he had met with Dorsey privately in 2018 and discussed implementing this privacy feature. 

While the hack only made off with approximately $120,000, it will persist as a lasting blight on centralized internet platforms for years. 

In view of Twitter’s unofficial role within politics and media as the broadcaster of all broadcasts, Rep. Frank Pallone (D-N.J.) said the hack could have had “major consequences” on elections. It’s a view shared by others. 

“With more than 300 million users, Twitter is a primary source of news for many, making it a target for bad actors. This type of hack by con artists for financial gain can also be a tool of foreign actors and others to spread disinformation and – as we’ve witnessed – disrupt our elections,” New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo said. 

With a federal investigation underway, “the hack is likely to continue to ratchet up pressure on social media companies, which are already facing scrutiny over content moderation, disinformation and foreign interference,” CoinDesk reports. 

But that doesn’t mean we’re any closer to a decentralized alternative. As Start9 Lab’s Matt Hill put it, the hack “is yet another wake-up call. And like most wakeup calls, it will be greeted with a snooze button and a growing sense of anxiety.

Market intel

First Mover
The notoriously volatile bitcoin slid just 0.8% to about $9,100 on Thursday, following the largest social media hack in recent memory, which involved an amateurish crypto scam. That’s in a market where it’s not uncommon for prices to swing 8% in a day. “It’s a non-event for price,” Matt Blom, head of sales and trading for the cryptocurrency firm Diginex, told First Mover in an email. The reasons for the non-event revolve around the contradictory and mostly-psychological readings of the event. Little in bitcoin was stolen, all publicity is good publicity and the hack shows how easy it is to track stolen crypto. Maybe most salient: Bitcoin is worth stealing. 

Opinion

Your Prime Membership Should Be Tokenized
Jeff Dorman, a CoinDesk columnist and chief investment officer at Arca, thinks Amazon Prime membership should be tokenized. Tokenization offers the clearest path to show digital ownership and maintain property rights, he said, but it also offers incentives for token owners to maintain, develop and propagate their platforms. In a sense, it’s the easiest way to link shareholders and users of a platform together. “This is the only path where capitalism and socialism can converge, and we’re seeing it happen in real time. Debt, equity and tokenized digital assets will all have a place in an investor’s portfolio and, more importantly, in customers’ portfolios. The lines are likely to blur as investors become active participants in the bootstrapped growth of the companies they love,” he writes. 

Meme police Related Stories
CoinDesk

US Agency Says Chinese Drug Traffickers Used Bitcoin to Launder Proceeds

6 years 2 months ago

The U.S. Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC), a division of the Treasury Department, sanctioned four Chinese nationals for allegedly using cryptocurrency to launder proceeds from illicit drug transactions.

In a press release Friday, OFAC announced that Songyan Ji, Longbao Zhang, Guifeng Cheng and Guangfu Zheng, as well as Global Biotechnology Inc., as providing support to the Zheng Drug Trafficking Organization under the Foreign Narcotics Kingpin Act.

Zheng DTO was also listed in a previous sanctions effort by OFAC, when the division added Xiaobing Yan, Fujing Zheng and Guanghua Zheng to its Specially Designated Nationals (SDN) list as narcotics traffickers last August.

Related: Hong Kong’s National Security Law Could Threaten Local Crypto Brokerages

“The Zheng DTO laundered its drug proceeds in part by using digital currency such as bitcoin, transmitted drug proceeds into and out of bank accounts in China and Hong Kong, and bypassed currency restrictions and reporting requirements,” the release said.

Unlike last August’s action, no bitcoin or other crypto addresses were added to the sanctions list. The release also did not indicate the magnitude of the alleged laundering.

OFAC’s action means it is attempting to seize all property belonging to the individuals in the U.S., and U.S. entities are now prohibited from dealing or transacting with the four designees.

Third action

Friday’s action is only the third time cryptocurrency has come up in an OFAC sanctions update. The agency first indicated it would add crypto addresses to its sanctions list in March 2018, saying crypto would be treated identically to fiat currencies as far as the SDN list was concerned.

Related: Iran Moves to Restrict Crypto Exchanges Under ‘Currency Smuggling’ Laws

The SDN list is OFAC’s blacklist for individuals or entities who the agency believes has violated U.S. law.

In addition to last August’s actions, OFAC has also sanctioned two Iranian residents it claimed were involved in laundering funds from the SamSam ransomware, which impacted government agencies and private entities.

That action, in 2018, marked the first time bitcoin addresses appeared on the SDN list.

Related Stories
CoinDesk

IRS Seeks Elliptic’s Crypto Tracing Software in Response to COVID-19

6 years 2 months ago

The U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is trying to license Elliptic’s cryptocurrency tracing software as an emergency response to COVID-19.

  • On July 15, the tax agency said it had negotiated a “COVID-19” crypto tracing deal solely with the British analytics firm under federal disaster relief law known as the Stafford Act, public records obtained by CoinDesk show.
  • President Donald J. Trump’s March declaration of a coronavirus emergency authorizes federal agencies to spend vast sums in response to the virus. That, apparently, is what is happening here.
  • CI Cyber Crimes wants to use the software for “tracing and analysis of various types of cryptocurrency transactions and the entities involved in transacting them,” the notice read, saying also that investigators asked for Elliptic by name.
  • The IRS did not immediately respond to CoinDesk’s queries as to why it needs crypto-tracing software to respond to COVID-19. However, the IRS has previously warned the public about COVID-19 fraud.
  • While the deal has already been negotiated, the full terms and dollar value are not yet publicly known. Additionally, competing firms have until July 22 to petition the IRS for consideration.
Related Stories
CoinDesk

Aave’s LEND Token Is Now Up 1,600% in 2020

6 years 2 months ago

There seems to be no stopping the LEND freight train: The native token of the decentralized lender Aave has risen by over 100% this month alone and is reporting stellar gains for the year so far.

  • At press time, LEND was up over 1,600% since Jan. 1, with the major part of the rally occurring over the past seven weeks.
  • The rapid gains look to have been driven by short-term traders and the rally may be over-extended, according to analysts at IntoTheBlock, a blockchain intelligence company. 
  • However the token’s value is also reflecting impressive growth in actual users of the lending protocol and optimism surrounding its recently launched Credit Delegation product.
  • Price rallies driven by fundamentals usually attract stronger buying pressure from investors.
  • Interestingly, the number of long-term LEND holders, as represented by addresses with coins static for more than a year, has declined 4% on a year-to-date basis to 151,730, also according to IntoTheBlock. 
  • That may indicate early users leaving the platform, but could also further indicate activity on Aave, with holders lending out their tokens.
  • Meanwhile, new users, or the number of addresses holding LEND for less than a month, has grown by almost 50% in just the last 30 days.
  • At press time, there are 4,630 LEND addresses compared to 1,100 addresses at the end of May.
  • Some argue that speculative frenzy is driving prices higher, drawing in traders, and the token looks vulnerable to a sudden bout of profit-taking.
  • “The current rally may be overextended as retail users enter the frenzy and large players appear to be selling,” analysts at IntoTheBlock told The Defiant.
  • The cryptocurrency was last seen trading at $0.287, representing a 14.7% gain on a 24-hour basis, according to data source Messari.
  • Prices hit a new 2020 high of $0.31 during the European trading hours on Friday.

Disclosure: The author holds no cryptocurrency at the time of writing.

Related Stories
CoinDesk

‘Wonder Woman’ Illustrator Jose Delbo to Release Comic Book on the Blockchain

6 years 2 months ago

Kapow! Watch out superhero fans, noted comic book illustrator Jose Delbo is releasing limited-edition art on a blockchain-based platform.

  • Delbo is the Argentinian artist responsible for DC Comic’s 1976-1981 “Wonder Woman,” Marvel’s 1988-1990 “Transformers,” “Billy The Kid,” and The Beatles’ “Yellow Submarine” comics.
  • The illustrator will premier new artwork on MakersPlace, a blockchain-powered market for rare and collectible digital art, later this month.
  • Two separate works will be released: a 43-page digital comic book and a digital Superman artwork by Delbo.
  • The digital comic book will be issued in a limited edition of 250 while the Superman artwork will be the only one of its kind.
  • The comic will explore serious themes including the coronavirus and the certainty of death.
  • The marketplace will use Ethereum to verify the artworks and provide a digital signature from Delbo.
  • The artist will also chat with fans about his art at a virtual reality exhibition to be hosted in Decentraland, where his recent work will also be displayed.
  • The artworks will go on sale at 20:00 UTC (4 p.m. ET) on July 23.

See also: The People of Decentraland Will Greet You Now

Related Stories
CoinDesk

First Mover: Why Bitcoin Traders Couldn’t Give a Sat About the Twitter Hack

6 years 2 months ago

Cryptocurrency traders yawned at one of the year’s biggest news stories for bitcoin, with prices barely budging as the digital-asset industry became a primary victim of this week’s massive hack on Twitter accounts.

The notoriously volatile bitcoin slid just 0.8% to about $9,100 on Thursday after slipping a meager 0.7% on Wednesday as the news hit. That’s in a market where it’s not uncommon, at least until recently, for prices to swing 8% in a day.  

You’re reading First Mover, CoinDesk’s daily markets newsletter. Assembled by the CoinDesk Markets Team, First Mover starts your day with the most up-to-date sentiment around crypto markets, which of course never close, putting in context every wild swing in bitcoin and more. We follow the money so you don’t have to. You can subscribe here.

Related: Twitter Says Hacker Group Targeted 130 Accounts

“It’s a non-event for price,” Matt Blom, head of sales and trading for the cryptocurrency firm Diginex, told First Mover in an email.

Scamming people out of their bitcoin was, at least on the surface, the goal of what the social-media platform called a “coordinated social engineering attack.” The hackers took over the Twitter accounts of the cryptocurrency exchanges Binance, Coinbase and Gemini, as well as those of celebrities including former Vice President Joe Biden and Microsoft founder Bill Gates. CoinDesk got hit, too.

As clues on the attack continue to trickle out, cryptocurrency analysts have begun to unpack the market implications for bitcoin – some positive and some negative – and why it all washes out.

“I think you did not see much market reaction because it was unclear what narrative would develop following the breach, and so traders were frozen,” John Todaro, of the cryptocurrency research firm TradeBlock, wrote in an email. 

Related: What Does the Twitter Hack Mean for Bitcoin? Crypto Reacts

1) The scale of the bitcoin obtained was relatively small. PRICE IMPACT: NEUTRAL. 

The bitcoin obtained through the hack amounted to roughly $120,000, a tiny fraction of the cryptocurrency’s $168 billion market capitalization. Less than one 10-millionth, in fact. That’s not too far off from the scale of the satoshi, or “sat,” which is the smallest unit of bitcoin, at one 100-millionth. Last year alone, there were at least seven major cryptocurrency exchange hacks, including $40 million from Binance and $49 million from South Korea’s Upbit.  

“The one thing that could have made it a bigger deal is if the hackers got more than $100K,” Martin Garcia, managing director at the cryptocurrency trading firm Genesis, wrote in an email. “If they had raised like $100 million, then I guarantee BTC would have sold off, as the market would have expected the hackers to sell to fiat somewhere, crushing the price. But given the amount, no big deal.”

(Genesis is owned by the investment firm Digital Currency Group, which also owns CoinDesk.) 

2) No publicity is bad publicity. PRICE IMPACT: POSITIVE. 

The episode could aid bitcoin’s name recognition, which theoretically could accelerate consumer adoption, at least on the margin. News articles about the hack appeared in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal and many other mainstream U.S. publications. The story was widely discussed on Twitter. Interest in the keyword “bitcoin” briefly surged on Google. 

“While I don’t condone the incident in any way, I must admit I’m pleased to see the rapid surge in popularity of bitcoin it has caused,” Jay Hao, CEO of the cryptocurrency exchange OKEx, wrote in a post on LinkedIn. “The hack itself is unfortunate, of course, but thanks to Twitter, bitcoin is grabbing the headlines again, and that can only be a good thing in the push to wider adoption.”

3) The episode could invite further regulatory and law-enforcement scrutiny of bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. PRICE IMPACT: NEGATIVE. 

The FBI said Thursday it’s investigating the event. U.S. Senator Josh Hawley, a Missouri Republican, called on Twitter to cooperate. New York Governor Andrew Cuomo directed the state to conduct a full investigation.

“Yesterday’s attack targeted the Twitter accounts of virtual currency companies,” Linda Lacewell, superintendent of the New York Department of Financial Services, said in a statement. “The department will leverage its deep expertise to bring the facts to light.”

4) The attack highlights the benefits of bitcoin’s decentralized network. PRICE IMPACT: POSITIVE. 

The fact Twitter’s systems appear to have been hacked could redirect attention to the fact that the Bitcoin blockchain is a distributed network of computers, reducing central points of failure or weakness. 

“It showcases weaknesses in centralized systems and a need for more decentralized applications,” Lennard Neo, head of research at Stack Funds, told First Mover in a WhatsApp message. 

5) Early efforts to track down the perpetrator and scammed bitcoin highlight the transparency of the blockchain network. PRICE IMPACT: POSITIVE. 

Private cryptocurrency-forensic firms including Chainalysis, CipherTrace and Elliptic have already started to probe the event, using publicly available data from the Bitcoin blockchain. As reported by CoinDesk’s Will Foxley, it appears the hacker was a trader on the crypto derivatives exchange BitMEX, and it’s pretty straightforward to document the inflows of bitcoin into the hacker’s listed account address as the scam unfolded. 

“You can track the crypto coming into the hacker crypto addresses,” the Binance-owned data website CoinMarketCap wrote Thursday in a blog post. 

6) Bitcoin is worth stealing. PRICE IMPACT: POSITIVE.

The billionaire investor Warren Buffett has said that bitcoin has “no value.” If that was the case, why steal it? 

“If anything, it just proves that bitcoin is a form of a valuable money that a hacker might want,” Jeff Dorman, chief investment officer of the cryptocurrency investment manager Arca, told First Mover in an email. 

7) Cryptocurrency is so frequently used in scams that the latest episode isn’t really all that surprising. PRICE IMPACT: NEUTRAL. 

“To say that everybody now knows that hackers prefer bitcoin has no effect, because everybody knows that already,” Mati Greenspan, founder of the cryptocurrency research firm Quantum Economics, said in a phone interview. 

8) The event could raise awareness of the imperative for security precautions among new cryptocurrency investors. It also might scare some would-be investors away. PRICE IMPACT: NEUTRAL.

CoinDesk’s Leigh Cuen reported Thursday that many authentic Twitter users were no longer able to tweet bitcoin addresses. 

“That has a huge silver lining, because it’s not good practice to publish your public key,” Greenspan said. “That’ll probably save a couple noobs from making noob mistakes.”

Tweet of the day Bitcoin watch

BTC: Price: $9,115 (BPI) | 24-Hr High: $9,157 | 24-Hr Low: $9,066

Trend: Bitcoin continues to stubbornly trade within a tight range above $9,000. The leading cryptocurrency hasn’t had a 5% daily move for 24 straight days, the longest stretch of such low daily volatility since the end of March 2019.

Prolonged periods of price consolidation tend to end with a sudden violent move on either side. So far, however, the cryptocurrency has refused to wake from its multi-month slumber. 

Technical studies indicate scope for a price drop in the short-term. For instance, the four-hour chart shows a failed breakout, a bearish sign. Meanwhile, the daily chart MACD histogram, an indicator used to identify trend strength and trend changes, has crossed below zero in favor of the bears. 

In addition, put options (or bearish bets) expiring in one- and three-months are drawing higher prices (or stronger demand) than call options (or bullish bets). As such, it seems traders are anticipating a sell-off. 

Immediate support is located at $9,000, which if breached, would shift the focus to $8,630 – the support of the higher low created on May 27. Meanwhile, resistance is seen at $9,480 (July 8 high). A move above that level is needed to invalidate a bearish lower-highs setup on the 4-hour chart and open the doors for $9,800-$10,000.

Related Stories
CoinDesk
Checked
16 minutes 57 seconds ago
CoinDesk Crypto
Leader in cryptocurrency, Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP, blockchain, DeFi, digital finance and Web 3.0 news with analysis, video and live price updates.
Subscribe to CoinDesk Crypto feed