Skip to main content

Fast Company

Anthropic’s IPO strategy? Cloak itself in altruism

3 weeks 2 days ago

Anthropic’s cofounders, including CEO Dario Amodei, left OpenAI because they believed AI safety features should be developed alongside model capabilities from the very start of the development process. This mission has shaped the company, and has carried through to the way it’s framing its IPO, which could happen before Thanksgiving. 

In its S-1 filing, Anthropic tells the story of a company that wants to benefit all of the world’s people, but can do so only if it goes big and leads the market. That smacks of effective altruism, a twenty-first-century philosophical approach that’s caught on with young Silicon Valley founders. Several Anthropic researchers told Wired in June that it’s important Anthropic stay in the lead among frontier artificial intelligence labs so that mass market AI will be built safely. Anthropic’s leaders believe that if the lab can reach major research milestones first, they can authoritatively define the safety regime needed to guard against the risk of the new capabilities.

But developing such safety regimes costs time and money. Challenged to maintain its lead, Anthropic might be tempted to make compromises on safety. Releasing a model quickly may improve Anthropic’s competitive position among AI labs but leave less time for safety testing. Or, restricting a model’s capabilities could reduce safety risks but limit its commercial value. 

Competitive pressure could encourage faster model development even when safety questions remain unresolved. The company has already shown a vulnerability to such pressure. In Anthropic’s original Responsible Scaling Policy, the company pledged that it would not develop or deploy certain advanced systems if it could not implement adequate safety measures. But in February 2026 Anthropic removed that categorical commitment from its policy, explaining that it couldn’t commit to halting development because it couldn’t count on its competitors doing the same.

Becoming a public company could itself complicate Anthropic’s safety ideals. Wall Street will demand constant quarterly revenue growth, not just to bolster investor confidence but also to offset the massive computing and infrastructure costs. The best way to do that is to hold onto existing customers and attract new ones, and that sets up another incentive to release ever more capable models as quickly as possible. 

That’s apparently what Anthropic has been doing. The S-1, which registers its securities with the Securities and Exchange Commission, shows that top-line revenues grew from approximately $4.6 billion for 2025 to $16.3 billion in just the first six months of 2026. 

Eventually, profits will matter just as much as revenue. Anthropic will have to develop and serve models in a way that generates bottom-line profit. The company reports a net loss of $80.7 billion for the first half of 2026, but says that only $693 million of that was lost from actual operations. The vast majority of it —more than $72 billion—came from shifting valuations of the complicated financial instruments (convertible notes, derivatives, etc.) that Anthropic has been using to raise money for future computing power and infrastructure build-out. The S-1 says that increases in Anthropic’s valuation caused increases in the fair value of its convertible promissory notes. 

At any rate, Anthropic’s proposition to investors depends on the demand for AI continuing, and accelerating. Today, there is no shortage of demand from the enterprise customers Anthropic wants to serve, but just because big corporations continue to buy access to more models and deploy AI in more ways doesn’t mean that the pace of adoption will continue. That depends on how quickly workers can adapt to new ways of doing business and gain trust in the accuracy of the AI.

And AI may not be delivering the broad productivity increases the industry is promising. Just two days before the Anthropic IPO, Apollo Global Management dropped a report saying that “despite massive investments and widespread hype around artificial intelligence, the technology has delivered zero financial payoff to corporate America outside of tech.” The firm’s chief economist, Torsten Slok, adds that revenue per worker is rising for the big seven tech companies, but is flat for the “S&P 493.” 

On the other hand, Apollo may be missing the point. What’s important for Anthropic is that enterprises continue to build their AI stack even if the returns aren’t yet hitting its balance sheet. Many of them are. According to the S-1, Anthropic has more than 11,900 customers—including half of the Fortune 500—that paid $100,000 or more over the past 12 months, with more than 1,900 of them paying $1 million or more over the same period, and approximately 250 of them paying $10 million or more.

Want to be happier? Oxford research says ask yourself these 3 questions

3 weeks 2 days ago

What does it take to be happy? Three simple and surprising questions may hold the answer, research found. While most of us seek more money and greater achievement as paths to happiness, these questions are all about connection. They’re more strongly associated with self-measured life satisfaction than either money or success. That’s according to the 2025 World Happiness Report published by Oxford University and based on a study of people in 147 countries. The questions are:

How often do you eat meals with other people, rather than alone?

Do you generally expect strangers to be kind and trustworthy?

How often do you do things for other people, such as making donations, volunteering, or helping strangers?

This may all sound like wishful thinking, but the research shows that, while economic security and career satisfaction contribute to happiness, these prosocial factors make a much bigger difference. If you want to be happy,

1. Eat with others

This is a rare instance where the report’s happiness advice coincides with frequently offered success advice to never have lunch alone. Lunching at your desk can mean missing out on valuable opportunities for networking or relationship building. It turns out it can also mean missing the chance to be happier by building a stronger social connection. Research suggests that we often expect spending time alone will make us happier than being with others, especially people we don’t know well. But then when we do spend time with others, it makes us happier than we expected.

The research looked at whether subjects ate with others or alone for lunch and dinner (it didn’t consider breakfast). Happiness appeared to peak at a whopping 13 lunches or dinners with others per week, which is more meal sharing than most Americans do. But it showed that any amount of eating with others will increase your happiness. So go ahead and grab yourself a lunch or dinner date, even if the person you invite isn’t a valuable business connection. It will make you feel more connected, and boost your happiness, too.

2. Expect strangers to be trustworthy

If you dropped your wallet on the street, how likely is it that someone would return it to you with the money still inside? World Happiness Report researchers found that most people underestimate how often they would get their wallets back in this scenario. They also found that those who thought the wallet return was likelier also tended to be happier.

But while eating with others would be an excellent business practice, trusting strangers probably isn’t. In a world where not every stranger is trustworthy, how do you balance the benefits of trusting strangers against the very real risks of trusting the wrong one?

But consider how many breakout companies are built on the outlandish idea that you can indeed trust strangers. Amazon, Facebook, Etsy, eBay, and other online marketplaces let strangers buy and sell from each other. Uber, Rover, and other such companies encourage us to put our safety, or that of our beloved pets, into the hands of people we’ve never met. Why do we trust these strangers? Because other strangers left reviews saying we could. It seems illogical and yet it works.

Does this mean you should blindly accept business propositions from people you don’t know without any due diligence? Of course not. You also should not leave your wallet in the street and assume someone will bring it back to you. But if you tend to automatically distrust anyone you don’t know, try to change that mindset. It will make you happier. It might make the people you do business with happier too.

3. Be kind to others

The report looked at three types of benevolent acts: donating, volunteering, and helping strangers. “The well-being benefits of benevolent acts depend on why and how people engage in them. Both helpers and recipients experience greater happiness from caring and sharing when they do so in the context of caring connections, choice, and clear positive impact,” the researchers write.

For one thing, choice is important. If you hear about a disaster in your area and feel inspired to make a donation to help, that’s likelier to make you happy than, say, feeling compelled to donate to a charity because your biggest customer or your boss has asked you to. And both giver and receiver of a benevolent act benefit more when they can see a clear positive impact. If you make a donation or volunteer your time to help rebuild a local park, and then spend time there watching people enjoy the park, you’ll get a bigger happiness boost. If the people there know you helped out and can thank you, they will too.

Performing benevolent acts gets you the biggest happiness result for the smallest effort. Being kind to other people doesn’t just make you happy, it makes them happy too, World Happiness Report researchers found. That may inspire those people to their own acts of kindness, inspiring others to be kind, and so on. Pretty soon, you might have a self-perpetuating happiness machine. That could benefit any organization or community.

—Minda Zetlin

This article originally appeared on Fast Company’s sister website, Inc.com. 

Inc. is the voice of the American entrepreneur. We inspire, inform, and document the most fascinating people in business: the risk-takers, the innovators, and the ultra-driven go-getters that represent the most dynamic force in the American economy.

The new Lego x Daft Punk collab makes perfect sense

3 weeks 2 days ago

Lego recently announced that Daft Punk, the French electronic duo that split up in 2021, is entering the Lego universe in a partnership that spans “product, content and brand experiences.” What the brick is this, you ask? Yet another damn licensing deal, now absurdly mashed up with a defunct electronica band?

As much as I dislike Lego’s reliance on IP licensing, this one makes all the sense in the world from a pure creative philosophy perspective. After speaking with Daft Punk’s and Lego’s creative leads, I think this is a contender for Lego’s best collab yet. 

[Image: Lego]

The first release will be a model of the pyramid stage from the duo’s Alive 2007 tour. At this point, Lego is not saying what it will cost, how big it is, or when it ships. Samuel Liltorp Johnson, the Lego creative lead on the project, says the design is still in development with the Daft Punk team and Patrick Harboun, a dad from Luxembourg who submitted it to Lego Ideas, the company’s platform on which Lego fans vote for the best models from other fans to be made into real commercial sets. For now, there’s just a short film of two robot minifigures following a glowing red brick to a DJ console, set to “Voyager” and “Human After All,” and a promise of more in 2027.

Cédric Hervet, Daft Punk’s creative director, tells me Daft Punk’s camp approached Lego back when the band was still active, but the timing wasn’t right. “For me, the end of the band was never the end of the robots,” he says. “A legacy keeps living through the people who take it on.” It was the fans who made it happen, he adds, by voting for a submission of the pyramid on Lego Ideas.

For Hervet, this “might be the best life the robots could have” after the band’s end. That’s because this mash-up goes deeper than just merch. It’s a matter of creative and design philosophies that go together as perfectly as Nile Rodgers and Daft Punk itself.

[Image: Lego] Faceless smiles and helmets

When the Lego designer Jens Nygaard Knudsen’s first minifigure went into production in 1978, it had the barest face imaginable: a pair of black dots and a painted smile on a yellow head. That was deliberate. “Sex, race and role were not to be part of the figure—they would be formed by the child’s imagination and play,” Lego explained in 2003.

The same smiling head worked as a cop, a knight, or an astronaut, depending on the hat and the story a kid had in mind. The face never changed, so the kid’s imagination did all the work. Most of today’s figures come with specific expressions and character features which, as I griped about back in 2013, suck. An angry minifig is stuck being angry forever, while the classic smile was a neutral placeholder.

[Image: Lego]

Daft Punk built their identity on an idea similar to Knudsen’s, only they replaced the face with an icon. Thomas Bangalter and Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo spent the late ’90s hiding behind masks and bags, then unveiled their robot helmets in 2001 with the album Discovery. Silver for Bangalter, and gold for Homem-Christo, both were engineered with help from the special effects designer Tony Gardner and wired with LED displays. For the next two decades, those two robots were Daft Punk. The helmets changed a bit over the years; the LED screens shrank and eventually went dark, but the robots never aged, never had a bad hair day, and never showed a human face.

[Image: Lego]

“I almost consider the character of the robots like a Marina Abramović performance art installation that lasted for 20 years,” Bangalter told the BBC in 2023, two years after the breakup. The robots became a fixed, faceless character and, eventually, a totem. That’s exactly what the 1978 minifig was for a generation of kids. 

Daft Punk’s helmets let two guys from France become no one. The helmets erased the people inside and turned the duo into a blank screen for the audience. “The helmets left all the room for the fans; everyone could project whatever they wanted onto them,” Hervet says. “And without the helmets, the robots might never have made it into the Lego universe.” 

A minifig wearing a Daft Punk helmet is two of the most famous blank faces in pop culture stacked on top of each other: a plastic person with no fixed identity, inside a pop star with no visible one. That stacking is the point, according to Hervet. What Daft Punk always protected, he says, “wasn’t access to the robots, it was their integrity.”

[Image: Lego]

Lego is also the perfect physical metaphor for the band. Hervet says that swapping pieces between figures is “a bit like sampling in music. You take an element, put it somewhere else, and it becomes something new.” Liltorp Johnson makes the same comparison: “Designing Lego sets is a lot like creating an electronic dance track. We sample from different elements and build them together to make the perfect composition.” They even remixed one of the band’s tracks, “Human After All,” into the partnership’s slogan, “Builders After All.”

Amid the brickstorm of movie, clothing, and comics licensing, consider this new collab the rare IP set that feels less like a brand stamping its logo on another brand, and more like two old design ideas finally meeting.

Biggest stock listing ever? A look at Anthropic’s IPO by the numbers

3 weeks 2 days ago

Anthropic has the chance to make history with what could be the biggest initial public offering of stock ever.

The artificial intelligence lab filed papers Monday setting up a Wall Street debut next month, ahead of its chief rival OpenAI and just months after SpaceX set records in June with an initial public offering that raised $86 billion.

In a 335-page prospectus, the company behind the Claude chatbot outlined rapid revenue growth, but an inability to turn a profit yet. The offering could bring in as much as $100 billion, according to reports, which would help to accelerate the expansion of the five-year-old startup.

The filing comes as Anthropic’s competitors like OpenAI are holding off on going public until next year, and as fears rise that the technology could slip free of human control to carry out harmful actions. Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei said the industry should slow its fast-moving development to give safety measures time to catch up.

But the company’s massive spending and revenue point to strong momentum.

Here’s a look at the key figures behind the lab’s ambitions.

Up to $2 trillion

That’s the reported valuation the company could reach once it goes public. This would surpass SpaceX’s initial valuation of $1.77 trillion and make Anthropic one of the world’s most valuable public companies. Nvidia, a maker of computer chips, leads that pack with a current valuation of more than $5 trillion.

Anthropic’s final valuation and offering price have not been established.

$131.7 billion

Anthropic said in the filing it had this amount available as cash or cash-equivalents as of June 30. The company also said its plans to build out compute and infrastructure are “changing the cash flow profile of our business” and will mean high capital expenditures.

$16.3 billion

This is Anthropic’s revenue in the first half of the year, which is about 14 times its revenue from the same period last year.

$80.7 billion

The amount of money Anthropic reported in net losses in the first half of the year. This included a one-time, $72.4 billion charge for an accounting adjustment related to financing agreements, according to the filing. It’s not uncommon for tech companies going public to not yet have turned a profit.

93

This is how many pages Anthropic used to enumerate risk factors for investors. Public companies are required by the Securities and Exchange Commission to disclose risk factors in their prospectus, but the lengthy nature of those in Anthropic’s is unusual.

Among the concerns were that advanced AI systems could pose “catastrophic or existential risks to humanity.”

250

The approximate number of customers Anthropic has that each account for $10 million or more of revenue in the past year. Anthropic did not disclose the names of its biggest customers in the filing, but it pointed to its top five customers representing approximately 25% of its revenue this year.

50.1%

The voting power Amodei and six other co-founders of Anthropic will hold at the company after it goes public. The company will issue a single share of a Class F common stock to a limited liability company organized by its co-founders. Amodei’s sister and Anthropic’s president, Daniela Amodei, is among the former OpenAI employees who left the company to create Anthropic in 2021.

—Associated Press

Apple’s Siri AI just got even more powerful in the iPhone’s latest iOS 27.2 update. You can download it today

3 weeks 2 days ago

Yesterday, Apple released a significant new software update for the iPhone: iOS 27.2 is packed with new features and bug fixes, adding more functionality to your phone.

But the software’s greatest enhancements bring new functionality to the company’s new artificial intelligence chatbot, Siri AI. Here’s what you need to know.

Siri AI gets smarter and more capable

When Apple released iOS 27 last month, it included dozens of improvements to the iPhone’s operating system.

But by far the star feature of iOS 27 was the completely revamped Siri AI. The new chatbot is Apple’s attempt to compete with more entrenched, well-known AI chatbots from OpenAI and Google. 

With iOS 27.2, Apple has now added even more functionality to Siri AI. Most notably, Siri AI can now remember past conversations you’ve had with it and remind you of that information, or use it to better answer your queries in a new chat.

Siri AI can now also pull data from a wealth of new sources to better answer your questions and more deeply understand your personal context. Now in iOS 27.2, Siri AI can pull data from your voicemails, Safari browsing history, photo attachments in Messages, Calendar event attendees, and more.

Apple has also added the ability to allow users to copy text from only part of a Siri answer, plus a revamped Settings pane where you can tell Siri to exclude apps as data sources for personal context around you.

In iOS 27.2, Siri also expands beyond an English-only chatbot. Now users can talk to and get replies from Siri in the following languages:

  • French
  • Japanese
  • Korean
  • Portuguese
  • Spanish
Messages and FaceTime get updates, too

Besides Siri AI, Apple also added some new features to two of its most popular apps: Messages and FaceTime. 

In iOS 27.2, Messages users will now see quick action suggestions below their iMessages that will allow you to add information from the iMessage to the Calendar, Notes, or Reminders app with a tap.

For example, if someone texts you information about a dinner reservation in the Messages app, an Add to Calendar button will show below the text, which will allow you to quickly add the event to the Calendar app.

Apple’s FaceTime app gains the ability to show “dual capture” content in group FaceTime calls on the iPhone 17 and later.

This means people in a group FaceTime chat will now be able to see video captures by both your front and rear iPhone cameras at the same time.

How to get iOS 27.2 on your iPhone today

iOS 27.2 is a free update for any iPhone that can run iOS 27. 

To download iOS 27.2 to your iPhone, do the following:

  1. Open the Settings app.
  2. Tap General.
  3. Tap Software Update.

The iOS 27.2 update will show on the Software Update screen. Follow the on-screen instructions to install it. When your phone restarts, you’ll have the iOS 27.2 operating system and all the features it brings to your iPhone.

DoorDash stock reacts on report that it wants to buy Instacart

3 weeks 2 days ago

A big change up could be coming to the food delivery sector.

DoorDash could soon be the new owner of Instacart. The food delivery service is said to be in advanced talks to purchase its rival for about $17 billion, the Wall Street Journal reports. 

A deal could be in place as soon as this week, though things are still reportedly tentative enough to fall through. Instacart was previously in sale talks with Uber, but those have since fizzled out. 

Instacart’s business focuses on home grocery shopping and delivery. While DoorDash has moved into that area, purchasing Instacart could give the restaurant delivery service a much stronger foothold in the market. 

DoorDash previously bought European food delivery service Wolt in 2022. 

Instacart declined to comment. DoorDash did not respond to a request for comment.

How are DoorDash and Instacart stocks performing? 

Following Monday’s report, shares of DoorDash (Nasdaq: DASH) closed 6.10% down, a drop of 25.63% year-to-date (YTD).

In contrast, Instacart’s stock price (Nasdaq: CART) was up 7.87% at the close of business, a 35.35% rise YTD. 

DoorDash is worth about $73 billion and shared positive results in its most recent earnings report. The company’s quarter two revenue rose 36% year-over-year (YOY) to $3.28 billion. It beat Wall Street’s expectations of $3.16 billion, according to consensus estimates cited by CNBC. 

Meanwhile, Instacart saw its second quarter revenue rise 14% YOY to $1.04 billion. 

3 design principles in the AI age

3 weeks 2 days ago

We live in a world where technology is evolving at a breakneck speed. It can be daunting, especially for designers, when tools that seem to replace us come out every week. What does it mean to be a designer today? What is good design anymore? How does one still produce it? These questions haunt a growing number of us, in design and across engineering, research, and product.

Good design has many definitions, but I believe it is refined, thought through, and connects emotionally and practically with its intended user. It is a singular and simple output or solution created and synthesized from diverse and complex inputs. By this definition, and despite everything changing around us, three principles for creating good design have held true through every technological shift.

Principle #1: The power of iteration. Great work must undergo numerous iterations on its journey to excellence. A timeless product is crafted through an experimental process marked by trial and error, continuous iteration, and occasional bursts of creativity. We must do and re-do work to unlock the challenges that help us reach greater levels of depth. Many great artists and inventors celebrated their iterations. As James Dyson said, “I made 5,127 prototypes of my vacuum before I got it right. There were 5,126 failures. But I learned from each one.”

In this process, we must learn to celebrate rough drafts as fiercely as we embrace finished products because a design is never truly complete. AI makes iterations faster and cheaper, but it hasn’t removed the need for them. We still have drafts. We still have iterations. It is rare that AI’s first output works perfectly, and if it does, we should be wary that it may be too generic.

With every new draft, we start to move towards our destination. With faster iterations, we must also reflect on what matters and what does not.As Antoine de Saint-Exupéry wrote, “Perfection is achieved, not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away.” In my own experience, I often find it takes 100 iterations before something feels right—a pitch deck, a feature, a physical product. But these iterations shouldn’t happen in a bubble.

Principle #2: The power of feedback. The process of co-creation enhances the quality and depth of work. Gathering feedback from diverse individuals brings a wealth of unique ideas and suggestions to each design iteration. Feedback can come in many forms—the inspirations of past designers, the voices of end-users, watching people in real life struggle through products or existing experiences, and more. It can also come from fabricators, engineers, designers, marketing teams, or other key stakeholders in true interdisciplinary fashion.

Again, AI has not changed this need, though we now have another feedback mechanism we can leverage. AI draws on a vast amount of knowledge when giving feedback. This is incredible, but we must be careful not to make AI feedback the only feedback. It is merely one source. It is important to learn which feedback to prioritize and when to bring it in, and to seek out diverse perspectives that lead to deeper, more thoughtful product innovation.

A famous Gujarati saying is, “The wise person listens to all but makes their own decision.” We also need to look more deeply at our own lens. We are the sum of many experiences and stories. We are complex creatures. It is easy to assume AI understands this and to trust it blindly, but it doesn’t. We need to dig deeper and make sure our own voices come through.

Principle #3: The power of connecting dots. Something magical happens in design when you give it time, like marinating food overnight in a bowl of spices or letting a curry simmer. Chemical reactions begin to take place, neurons have conversations in the dark, the dots start to connect. When we take a step back from our work, we can zoom out. This can help us see a bigger picture and how the story connects. We start to see what is important and what is not. How does our work connect with where we started? Have we steered off course?

AI can help us make stronger connections and hold the journey of design more easily, but only if we let it. Remembering the narrative—the valuable “in-between” knowledge, steps, and design assets amassed during the design journey—has historically been a challenge. Capturing it creates a blueprint of how a design took shape. It highlights crucial decision-making points and provides a framework for future evolutions. This wealth of data and context helps us make our own process smarter. We can see which iterations mattered most, and where we can draw inspiration from our other work. But AI’s speed may be faster than what we can process. We must step away from our screens, go for walks, see friends and family, visit cafes, and then return to our work. Only then do we allow the time needed for processing to occur.

Every generation has had its technological revolution—from pencils to printing presses, and steam engines to electricity, and now computers to automation. Every generation has likely faced similar fears as the ground shifted beneath its feet. Will I adapt? Will I be replaced? Is what I know and worked so hard to learn still relevant? Somehow, despite all these transformations across time, certain human principles have endured and guided us.

In design, these principles still remain, through constant iterations, intentional feedback, and stepping away to see the bigger picture before zooming back into the details. Designers will survive this era and will help shape it. In fact, designers’ adaptability might just be one of the most important qualities of all.

Saad Rajan is CEO and cofounder of Naya Studio.

Urban acupuncture in the age of AI

3 weeks 2 days ago

AI is rapidly transforming every aspect of work and life. According to Stanford University’s human-centered artificial intelligence 2026 AI Index Report, AI adoption is spreading at historic speed, with generative AI reaching 53% global adoption within three years of its introduction, faster than the PC or the internet at the same stage. Eighty-eight percent of organizations have adopted AI, and 80% of university students currently use generative AI.

But the voracious need for AI infrastructure to support this growth is colliding with physical limits. The electricity demands, plus land and water usage driven largely by data centers, have triggered backlash, and local communities are increasingly becoming battlegrounds for big tech.

So what is at the crux of this tension? I spoke with Cecilia Caparas Apelin, brand marketing expert and cofounder of CIEL Creative Space, a 50,000+-square-foot, multi-use creative campus in Berkeley, California, to find out. We discussed the role of the physical environment on the health of communities, the rising appetite for analog experiences, and “urban acupuncture” as a catalyst for growth.

Q: You honed your branding chops working on iconic consumer lifestyle brands, such as Gap Inc. and Condé Nast. Then you pivoted to tech, creating marketing campaigns for Airbnb, Facebook, Logitech, and Samsung. What did you learn from these experiences?

Cecilia: One of the most important things I learned was how easily the human intention behind an idea can get lost as it moves through an organization.

I spent a lot of time talking with founders, inventors, and engineers about what they were trying to create and what human problem they were trying to solve. Often, the original intention was incredibly clear. But somewhere between invention, engineering, and bringing a product to market, that simplicity could disappear.

My role in marketing was often to bring everyone back to the human truth. What does this mean in someone’s life? How does it make them feel? Why should they care? We would literally say, “Humanize it. Keep it simple. Keep it real.” You can build the most innovative product in the world, but if people can’t understand it or connect with it, you’ve lost something essential.

That philosophy has stayed with me throughout my career. Technology should serve human behavior, not require humans to reorganize themselves around technology.

Q: How did you end up founding CIEL?

Cecilia: I had always wanted to hold space for other creatives.

Throughout my career, I had the privilege of working in studios and creative environments all over the world. I started noticing what made certain spaces feel incredible to create in, not just aesthetically, but energetically and operationally. I was quietly collecting those lessons for years. CIEL became the culmination of those experiences.

Yes, we’re a production studio. But we’re also a place for events, conversations, music, art, fashion, technology, and community. Our larger mission is simple: Make space to be human.

I believe creativity is part of our birthright. And increasingly, I think physical spaces have a responsibility to protect and cultivate it.

We’re not interested only in creating content. We’re interested in creating conditions where people can connect, experiment, make something, experience something, and hopefully leave a little different than when they arrived.

Q: In your branding, you talk about urban acupuncture. What is that?

Cecilia: Urban acupuncture is a philosophy that my cofounder Alexis introduced me to by Brazilian architect, Jaime Lerner. He studied the social economics of a neighborhood. If you think of acupuncture in the body as releasing energetic blocks throughout all the chakras, he did that within a neighborhood. So it’s about understanding what the “key chakras” are within a neighborhood and putting something in the neighborhood that doesn’t disrupt the flow.

Our space is incredibly intentional. We looked at different blocks within this neighborhood to make sure we would be a good fit. We are surrounded by other creatives—from architects to filmmakers to bakers. CIEL became a connective point, a place where different communities could cross paths, collaborate, and create economic and cultural activity together.

To me, that’s urban acupuncture. It’s not disruption for disruption’s sake. It’s understanding the existing energy of a place and making an intentional intervention that allows more life to happen around it.

Q: What do you feel your space provides in a world that’s so digital and AI-driven? 

Cecilia: As technology becomes more powerful, I think physical spaces become more important, not less.

As much as I am committed to preserving our humanity, I’m not anti-tech. I spent years working in this industry. AI can make us faster, more productive, and open up possibilities we couldn’t imagine before, but we can’t let efficiency come at the expense of our humanity.

We need spaces for curiosity, serendipity, creativity, connection, and flow. We need places where you can walk in, disarm the ego, release the filters, and become curious again.

That’s what I want CIEL to provide—a blank canvas where you don’t have to arrive knowing exactly what the outcome is going to be.

AI is already here. The question for me is how we use it without giving up our agency, creativity, and humanity in the process.

Q: Do you have hope?

Cecilia: Absolutely. I have so much hope for humanity. I see it whenever I’m around people who have that creative drive and a strong desire to do something meaningful in the world. There’s something powerful that happens when we ask “What could we create together?”

AI is going to transform how we work and create, but I don’t believe the future belongs only to the people building the most powerful technology. It belongs to the people building the spaces, communities, and experiences that remind us what it means to be human.

Celia Jones is global chief marketing officer of FINN Partners.

Retail’s delivery boom is here

3 weeks 2 days ago

Retail promised fast, on-demand delivery before it had a way to pull it off. Food apps spent a decade training all of us to expect it, and that expectation has spread to paint and lumber, bulk groceries, and things nobody ever planned to move in under an hour.

This past year, Sam’s Club switched on one-hour delivery across 600 clubs and pushed 65,000 of those orders out in a few weeks. Uber Eats started sending drivers to collect retail returns off people’s porches. Yet while those numbers will likely be stale by next quarter, the shift they point to won’t be. In areas that were never built for it, fast delivery has gone from nice-to-have to expected.

Underneath it is software making thousands of small calls an hour, deciding who picks up each order and how it reaches the door. The fix everyone reaches for is the AI agent. Most of what’s sold today isn’t ready. As of June 2025, Gartner counts only about 130 legitimate vendors among the thousands now selling agentic AI, and expects more than 40% of agentic AI projects to be scrapped by the end of 2027.

The whole argument fixates on the wrong thing. Everyone wants to know what the AI can do. But in spending years connecting retailers to delivery networks, I’ve learned to ask something narrower: What has this software earned the right to decide in your operation?

AUTONOMY AS SOMETHING YOU BUY

One trap is what Gartner calls agent washing: a chatbot or rules engine relabeled an “AI agent” and priced like one.

The other trap is the full-autonomy pitch, software that supposedly runs the whole operation. That one should scare any operations lead who answers for missed deliveries.

Both treat autonomy as something you install and flip on. Autonomy is trust, granted by an operator, one type of decision at a time. No vendor can install that for you.

The buyers are figuring this out. A year ago, the first question in most of my meetings was “Do you have AI?” Now it’s “What does AI decide on its own, and what does it hand to a person?”

LET THE RECORD DECIDE

Delivery is where I’d make the machine prove itself.

When an order comes in, it chooses the provider most likely to get it there on time. Then that provider accepts the job and stalls while the window closes. At some point, waiting becomes the riskier call, and the order needs to move somewhere else. We don’t have to spend three quarters debating whether the machine handled either decision well. Within an hour, the customer has the order, or they don’t.

Every operation already keeps two records: what moved, and what it cost. Almost nobody keeps the third: why each order went the way it did. That third record is what lets you grade the machine.

Run the machine’s calls next to your dispatchers’ calls for a month, with the reasons on both sides, and count: how often they agree, each side’s on-time rate, how often a person steps in and is right. Where the machine wins that comparison, stop reviewing every decision. Where it doesn’t, it recommends and a person approves. And it runs the other way: Break a rule you set, and that authority comes back to a person on the spot, no meeting required. That’s the whole system.

One decision might earn its way through in 30 days, another in a year. If the dispatcher is still seeing something the machine isn’t, the dispatcher keeps the call. Once the machine has the better record, paying someone to rubber-stamp it is wasted motion. What shouldn’t change is how a decision earns the crossing: on evidence from your own operation, not a vendor demo.

WHAT STAYS WITH PEOPLE

Assume the AI models keep getting better. Assume routing, batching, ETAs, all of it gets solved. Two parts of this business will still run on people.

The first is the physical aspect of delivery. However good routing gets, a person still has to pick the order up and get it to the door. Sometimes that’s a can of paint on a porch. Sometimes it’s a new phone at a gated community with no gate code, nobody answering the callbox, and a driver burning through the delivery window. Whatever the doorstep robots turn out to be good at, they aren’t carrying catering trays up a stairwell anytime soon. For most retail delivery, the last 50 feet is a person.

The second is accountability, and it’s the one people underrate. Software optimizes against whatever goals you hand it, so the real work is deciding what those goals should be for a particular retailer serving particular customers—a judgment call somebody has to make and then live with. A $3,000 washer and dryer going to a third-floor walk-up needs a two-person crew who’ll haul the old pair out, hook up the new ones, and run a cycle before they leave. No model knows that until a person tells it.

That work gets heavier as the software improves, when fewer decisions are made by hand, each one covers more ground.

MOVE THE LINE ON PURPOSE

None of this slows down. There’s another retailer next quarter, another promise to keep, and the software keeps earning its way into more of the work whether anyone’s watching or not. So go ask whoever runs your dispatch floor which decisions it makes without a person in the loop, and what it did to earn each one. If the answer isn’t written down anywhere, the line already moved and nobody decided to move it.

Vendors will keep telling you what AI can do, and increasingly they’ll be right. What none of them can tell you is what it should be deciding in your operation, on your accounts, against the promises you’ve made. That part was never theirs to sell.

Salman Habib is cofounder of Burq.

The lesson of the Theranos film for today? Before you buy the AI claim, ask to see everything

3 weeks 2 days ago

Thirty-four days before reporting to federal prison, Elizabeth Holmes opened her private life to a film crew. Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim kept filming for about three years, and the result, You Can See Everything, opened in theaters this month to huge box office and wide acclaim. The title echoes a scene in which Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans, promise the camera it can indeed see everything.

The film invites a true-crime reading. But as someone who builds agentic customer experiences for brands, I see a story about how trust is won and what happens when the product can’t justify it. Theranos was a brand long before it had a working product, and every signal it sent said the same thing: Trust us. The product couldn’t back any of it up. That should worry anyone writing a brand promise right now, especially one about artificial intelligence.

Borrowed credibility runs out

Theranos collected trust the way some brands collect logos. In 2014, Fortune described its board as three former cabinet secretaries, two former senators, a retired Navy admiral, and a retired Marine general. Holmes wore the black turtleneck and called her invention the iPod of health care, and the Steve Jobs comparisons followed.

Each of those signals lent credibility. None of them created it. Borrowed trust works like a loan; the product eventually has to repay it, and when it can’t, the brand pays. Any brand that leans on a famous partner, endorser, or technology name to carry a claim should ask what happens the day the product gets examined on its own.

That test applies to my firm too. Apply has strong partnerships with Google Cloud, Anthropic, Amazon, and OpenAI, and we are proud of them. But a partner’s name is a foundation, not proof. Make every agency, including mine, prove what it can deliver.

Access isn’t proof

An open door is different from openness. Anyone can offer to show you everything and still control what you see. Brands do the same thing when they treat transparency as a performance: the trust page, the responsible AI statement, the demo built to be watched. A responsible AI page that lists principles but names no owner is a good test. If no one can say who answers for the claim, the page is merely decoration.

Ask to see everything, and ask to choose what you see; unscripted, on your own data, including the failure log. Real transparency shows you where the product falls short as clearly as where it shines.

The AI version is already here

In many agencies, using AI means people are using ChatGPT or Claude on top of the same delivery workflows they ran before. That is a faster tool inside the same process, good for a 20%-30% efficiency gain. Calling it AI-native or agentic makes the claim bigger than the change.

At Apply, we rebuilt our delivery model to be agentic-native on a proprietary platform and trained our entire workforce to work that way, instead of adding AI on top of the old workflow. I’d encourage you to ask every agency you hire what, specifically, they changed. Reimagining the model, not just the tools, is where 20%-30% can become 20x-30x.

Brands are making AI claims their products can’t support yet, and agencies like mine are helping write them. “Autonomous,” “agentic,” and “AI-powered” are easy to write and hard to back up. I’m not calling any brand a fraud. Building these systems means seeing what they can and can’t do the day after the demo.

How the gap becomes normal

After the space shuttle Challenger disaster, the sociologist Diane Vaughan described what she called the normalization of deviance: Small departures from what is safe get accepted one at a time until they are simply how the work is done.

AI claims drift the same way. The first time, the copy says “autonomous” when a person still handles the exceptions, and nothing goes wrong. The next campaign borrows the wording. By the third, the gap between the claim and the product is just the house style. I wrote about this in the context of AI governance. The people closest to the work are often the first to see the gap and the least likely to say so. Ask your agency to tell you where the work falls short before it ships.

Pressure-test the promise before it goes out

Before any AI claim goes into your campaign, ask your agency three questions.

  1. Can you show it working in production, failures included? Ask for evidence from real data and real workflows, including what went wrong.
  2. Whose name is on it? Put one person’s name behind the claim and the results that support it. People ask harder questions when they know they’ll have to answer for the outcome.
  3. What happens when it fails? Be clear about where the system needs human help, and make sure the promise reflects that limit. Test the handoff before launch, or your customers will be the first to find out where it breaks.

We hold ourselves to the same questions. At Apply, our teams are about half people and half agents. The agents extend the people, and every deliverable has a named human owner. That works only because accountability is assigned before the work begins, which makes it human ownership, a step beyond a human in the loop. We’re still learning.

Before a claim reaches a customer, someone has to ask the hard questions and have the authority to act on the answers. At Theranos, those questions were ignored, and an employee who raised concerns was met with legal pressure to stay quiet. A brand earns trust by making sure the evidence shapes the promise, rather than letting the promise outrun the evidence.

This is how marketers can win in the age of AI

3 weeks 2 days ago

According to Ipsos, two-thirds of American marketers would fail a basic marketing test. The market research company’s study found that most marketers couldn’t answer even basic questions about the fundamentals of their own profession. Fully 40% didn’t know what “positioning” meant, 54% didn’t know what “above the line” meant, and half didn’t know what “penetration” meant.

Not surprisingly, the study sparked panic in the form of dozens of articles and Linkedin thought pieces blaming the decline in marketing fundamentals for everything from bad advertising to the discipline’s waning influence within the corporate hierarchy.

Rather than add to the fearmongering, I’d like to posit another perspective on the erosion of basic marketing skills. My question is this: In the age of artificial intelligence, does it really matter?

I ask this mostly facetiously, but also as someone who reluctantly must concede that the strategic output of tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and the like are actually . . . well . . . pretty damn good. If you take the time to properly prompt any of these tools on your market conditions and objectives, the recommendations it brings back are typically quite sound. Perhaps even better than what your average human marketer might come up with on their own—particularly if it’s one of the marketers who didn’t know what “positioning” meant. In fact, with this vast knowledge base at the fingertips of every marketer, there is no longer any excuse for having a genuinely “bad” strategy.

AI has flattened marketing strategy

But as AI slowly eliminates bad strategy, it is also accelerating strategy’s homogenization. Now that everyone is using AI to help them write their strategies, two things are happening. The floor is being raised, and simultaneously the ceiling is being lowered. Everyone is relying on the same tools to write their strategies. As a result, over time everyone will be running the same playbook.

I recently spoke to a pitch consultant who told me that it’s harder than ever for clients to evaluate the strategic output of prospective agency partners. The reason: They all use AI to write their strategies and everyone comes in and presents slightly different versions of the same thing. And it’s not just pitch teams leaning on AI for their strategies; it’s everyone. On both the agency and marketing sides I regularly encounter strategies that I’m confident are heavily indebted to large language models.

So, in a world where not just our products, but also our strategies, are commoditized, how do marketers create a competitive advantage?

Execution matters more than ever

The first answer to that question is simple in theory, but hard in practice—execution. It’s easy to have ChatGPT spit out a strategy to drive distinction, accelerate demand, and grow your business. But it’s as hard as it’s ever been to turn that strategy into a reality.

Words in a deck are easy enough; galvanizing an organization and transforming them into action is hard. If two football teams are working with the same playbook, it’s the one who can execute that playbook more effectively who will win the game.

Break the rules

“I want to do my best to execute theoretically sound strategies, while always paying close attention and constantly looking for reasons to deviate and play an exploitative strategy.”—Justin Saliba, two-time World Series of Poker winner

In poker there’s something called “playing by the book.” It’s when a player makes the mathematically correct choices in a given situation. “The book” basically breaks down every poker scenario into a mathematical percentage of your likelihood to win the hand. Over time, someone who consistently plays by the book will beat someone who always plays by their gut. But the best players are the ones who play by the book most of the time—and also know when to strategically throw it away.

ChatGPT is the book. It’s an aggregation of all the data out there distilled into what you should do. But if everyone is playing by the book, your competitive advantage comes from knowing when to deviate from that.

Bravery now more than ever

It’s true that the marketing discipline has been pushed to the sidelines in many organizations. One reason is that marketers have become overly reliant on data. If ChatGPT is writing our strategies, research is dictating our creative choices, and media platform algorithms are taking care of the rest, then it’s not surprising that perceived value is diminished.

We are entering an era where, more than ever, brave choices that deviate from the data will be rewarded. This is not a call to arms to be reckless. But the truth is, sometimes the data gets it wrong. And sometimes people don’t know what they want. And sometimes, AI can’t tell you what to do next because all its data is based on everything that’s already been done.

For decades we’ve been using strategy to outperform commoditized categories. Now is the time to use execution and intuition to outperform commoditized strategies.

These tiny trackers were designed to be light enough for a butterfly

3 weeks 2 days ago

Researchers track animal movements through tags on their limbs, wings, and shells, but how do you track a creature that weighs less than a gram? To build a device tiny and light enough for a monarch butterfly, designers had to make the smallest wildlife tracking device on the planet.

A tiny transmitter for butterflies designed by the New Jersey-based Cellular Tracking Technologies (CTT) is called the BlūMorpho. It’s just three-and-a-half centimeters (1.4 inches) long, weighs about as much as a grain of rice, and works without a battery.

[Image: Courtesy Vermont Center for Ecostudies]

CTT manufactures devices for wildlife telemetry, or tracking the movements and migration patterns of wild animals. After bringing its manufacturing in-house during the COVID-19 pandemic, it was able to make minuscule parts on its own.

“We’ve been a telemetry company since 2007, and we work primarily with birds, so everything is about saving weight,” David La Puma, CTT’s vice president of global market development, tells Fast Company. Designing for a butterfly’s weight, however, was “an extreme constraint,” La Puma says, adding that designing and manufacturing the product took significant investment.

[Photo: Kent McFarland/Courtesy Vermont Center for Ecostudies]

Instead of a battery, the tracker uses a super tiny solar panel, smaller than the torch on the back of a dime, that’s located at the top of the transmitter. Most of the device is a skinny antenna that runs down the body of the model and transmits information to fixed receiver stations.

In spring 2025, 30 butterflies equipped with BlūMorpho were released from Ontario, Canada, by Environment and Climate Change Canada to track their migration south as part of a research collaboration, Project Monarch. More than 400 butterflies were tagged and tracked last fall, a number that grew to about 1,500 this year, and the goal is to reach more than 2,000 butterflies after tagging over the winter. Being able to gain insights could be helpful at a time when butterflies are in decline due to threats like climate change and habitat loss.

[Image: Cape May Point Arts and Science Center]

At the Vermont Center for Ecostudies, conservationists are using the trackers to determine how many Vermont Monarchs make it south to Mexico, and if they don’t, where the threats and bottlenecks are along the way. They’re also using the trackers to determine whether the butterflies have a better chance of surviving if they migrate earlier in the year.

Staff at the center are able to put the trackers on the butterflies after placing the butterflies in a fridge for about 20 minutes to slow them down. From there, a butterfly is placed on a spreading board with its wings spread under small weights to keep them from moving. The transmitter is then glued to the butterfly’s thorax with nontoxic eyelash glue that dries in 15 minutes. After a short time in a temporary cage to make sure the tracker is working, the butterfly is released into the wild.

“With these transmitters, it’s the first time we can actually see the movements of individuals. We’ve never been able to do that before,” says Desirée Narango, a conservation scientist at the center.

[Photo: Cape May Point Arts and Science Center/Courtesy CTT]

The center’s staff have found that butterflies take various migratory paths across a broad geographic area. They’ve been able to see how fast they fly, how far, and how long their sustained flight is, as well as the approximate location they are stopping to find nectar and refuel. That could be a small pollinator garden in a backyard or school, or near threats like roadways and pesticides.

“Being able to see just how important these small patches of habitat are for their migratory journeys has been eye opening,” she says, and they’re now talking about potentially using these transmitters on dragonflies or bumblebees, too.

“There are a number of migratory insects here in North America that we know almost nothing about,” she says. “This technology will really revolutionize our understanding of migratory behavior.”

The secret strategy behind Whoop’s $10.1 billion valuation

3 weeks 2 days ago

When former Harvard squash cocaptain Will Ahmed developed the idea for wearable company Whoop in the early 2010s, he was focused on helping serious athletes like himself optimize their performance. The wristband he designed tracks activity, sleep, and recovery. But in August, the Whoop founder and CEO turned his attention to a very different audience: Medicare recipients.

The Whoop Connected Care offering—which includes a Whoop membership, a Whoop device, and a third-party blood pressure monitor and cuff—is now a pilot program available to Medicare beneficiaries 65 and older who have been diagnosed with hypertension, prediabetes, high cholesterol, or obesity. “Continuous data matters,” says Dr. Ami Bhatt, a board-certified cardiologist who joined Whoop as chief medical officer over the summer. “People want to perform and age well, and that’s what we’re aiming for.”

Bhatt acknowledges that at first glance, American seniors appear to have little in common with the athlete ambassadors—like international soccer star Cristiano Ronaldo and Super Bowl-winning NFL quarterback Patrick Mahomes—most closely associated with the Whoop brand. But women older than 60 are one of Whoop’s fastest-growing customer segments. They’re bellwethers of a broader shift as consumers’ pursuit of wellness morphs into a deeper interest in preventive healthcare. Wearable companies, looking to cash in on the trend, are hiring doctors like Bhatt and courting clinical partners.

Whoop and Oura, among the buzziest wearables on the market, are already multibillion-dollar businesses. Whoop was valued at $10.1 billion in March, when it raised $575 million in Series G funding. Oura was valued at $11 billion at the time of its $900 million Series E round last year.

But there are only so many weekend warriors and wellness hobbyists willing to pay hundreds of dollars a year to track their steps and minutes of deep sleep. The key to attracting bigger audiences and keeping them engaged, wearable companies posit, is to connect the devices’ data to meaningful medical insights. And if that also allows a company like Whoop to tap into Medicare’s $1.2 trillion budget, all the better.

Bhatt, who previously served as inaugural chair of the Food and Drug Administration’s Digital Health Advisory Committee and chief innovation officer at the American College of Cardiology, says wearable companies shouldn’t position themselves to replace clinical care. But they can certainly supplement it. “What we need to be doing is helping people understand their baseline and helping clinicians understand what’s happening in between visits,” she says. “I want them to get a comprehensive addition and context to the story since they last saw that patient.” 

Silicon Valley is home to a graveyard of abandoned hardware devices, left behind as consumer tastes change. Whoop and Oura plan to escape that fate by embedding themselves more deeply in healthcare. 

Not-quite medical devices

The backdrop to this expanding mandate for wearables is a simmering debate over regulation. Historically, the FDA has clearly delineated between general wellness devices and medical devices. Medical devices, which are subject to stringent rules and approvals, are designed to diagnose and treat specific diseases and conditions. Wellness devices, in contrast, are designed to support healthy lifestyles more broadly. Wearables like Whoop and Oura are deliberately upending that distinction. 

“The latest generation of wearables delivers clinical-grade insights,” Oura CEO Tom Hale wrote in a Wall Street Journal op-ed last December calling for a change in federal policy. 

Whoop, for its part, stood its ground when the FDA sent a warning letter last summer questioning a feature the company had built to track blood pressure. The company edited its app interface to clarify that the feature was not diagnostic, but otherwise refused to compromise. 

In January, the FDA capitulated. It issued new guidance that gives wellness devices far greater leeway to measure the physiology associated with chronic conditions. Six months later, the agency dropped its enforcement action against Whoop’s blood pressure feature. 

[Image: Whoop]

The companies have been racing to take advantage of the friendlier rules and solidify their positioning as healthcare solutions. In May, Oura unveiled a partnership with virtual care provider Counsel Health. When a user’s biometrics show what Oura describes as “major signs of strain,” based on measures like body temperature and resting heart rate, the device maker now sends an email suggesting that it’s time to “Connect with a Doctor who has context.” 

As for Whoop, members can upload their medical records; complete blood work with partner Quest Diagnostics to evaluate more than 100 biomarkers; and connect with doctors on-demand. Whoop’s top-tier device is named the Whoop MG, short for “medical grade”—even though it’s not an FDA-approved medical device.

Data meets reality

Researchers and clinicians caution that a gap remains between the products as they exist today and the practical realities of delivering care. 

Sandeep Kishore, a physician-scientist and associate professor at the University of California, San Francisco, is part of an effort to reimagine care for chronic conditions with the help of digital tools. Wearables have “potential,” he says, but at the moment we’re in what he describes as a “twilight zone.” Devices are generating reams of data, but the algorithms behind that data are typically proprietary and difficult to independently validate. 

For example, Whoop offers a feature called Blood Pressure Insights, and Oura offers what it calls NighttimeBP. Because the companies say they have designed these data insights for wellness purposes, and not for the purposes of clinical diagnosis, the features are exempt from the rules that govern traditional blood pressure cuffs. 

“Nighttime BP does not display mmHg values,” Oura explains in its FAQs, referencing millimeters of mercury, the standard unit of measurement for blood pressure. “It shows dipping patterns and trends, not absolute blood pressure measurements.”

But that isn’t stopping patients—er, wellness consumers—from bringing these measurements and others to their doctors. “I’m having a bunch of unvalidated data coming in to me, and I’m being asked to react to that,” Kishore says. 

Emerging research suggests that even more established wearables still suffer from accuracy problems. A paper published in Nature this past January found that Apple Watch excels in some physiological and behavioral measurements, like heart rate at rest, but fails in others, like energy expenditure. 

Chronic conditions and more

Despite such shortcomings, device makers are finding that some healthcare providers are willing to experiment. After all, three in four American adults lives with a chronic condition. “The current system isn’t working,” Chris Curry, an ob-gyn and clinical director of women’s health at Oura, says of the refrain that she hears from Oura’s clinical partners. “Let’s try something new.” 

Oura has built a feature for users taking GLP-1 medications, for example. “We’re not trying to replace the doctor prescribing the GLP-1,” she says. “But the physicians who are in that world have a hard time keeping track of all their patients. And so we built the GLP-1 experience to be part of the solution. ‘My body’s changing really quickly—is everything okay?’”

Curry can imagine Oura playing a deeper role in the future. “The literature suggests that not every med is perfect for every person,” she says. “We don’t know why yet. I think [Oura] is well positioned to ask questions, and then ideally find the answers. Are there optimal dosings for certain categories of people? Are there things that are happening under the hood to your cardiovascular system or your metabolic system that are differentiated from weight loss, and we should also be tracking or managing in different ways? We want to be part of the scientific literature that lets physicians more smartly prescribe.”

Bhatt, meanwhile, has been seeking collaborators in specialties she sees as priorities for Whoop, including cardiometabolic health, women’s health, and neurology. The company is also teaming up with the National Council on Aging and AARP to tailor its user experience for older audiences.

“They say 80 is the new 50, right?” Bhatt says. Or it could be, if Whoop can prove that its devices can improve health outcomes. Deliver on that promise, and everyone—consumers, doctors, insurers—will be knocking on her door.

How much will data centers increase your electric bill?

3 weeks 2 days ago

One of the biggest reasons most Americans don’t want a data center built nearby is that they worry it will drive up their utility bills. But whether those bills rise, and by how much, depends on the local power grid and the terms of the deal.

In fact, the impacts have at times been counterintuitive, with new data centers in some cases actually driving down utility bills for other customers on the same grid.

Consider North Dakota. A 2025 study from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and the Brattle Group found that increased electricity demand from large customers, including data centers, helped lower bills in the state between 2019 and 2024. That’s partly because North Dakota had a relatively abundant supply of electricity, including wind power, and didn’t necessarily need to build new infrastructure to accommodate the additional demand. Instead, utilities could spread their existing costs across more customers, bringing bills down. (That dynamic becomes less likely as the grid runs out of spare capacity, but more on that later.)

The study found that over that five-year period, there were several reasons that prices were rising other locations. Inflation was one obvious driver. But there were a range of other significant causes, from Russia’s war in Ukraine impacting the price of gas for power plants to the cost of utilities making the grid more resilient to wildfires in places like California.

To get a clearer picture of how data centers affect electricity costs, researchers at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School and Harvard Business School took a different approach. In a new working paper, they compared electricity bills in places where data centers were built between 2020 and 2025 with bills in areas that didn’t see new construction. “We started looking at this earlier this year…there was a lot of public perception about what data centers are doing, but strong academic and critical evidence on what the real impacts are was missing,” says Vishrut Rana, a Wharton doctoral student and one of the study’s authors.

That research has found that new data centers had a relatively small impact on residential bills over the study period—on average, just 4% of the total observed increase. (Industrial energy prices jumped up higher.) The impact varied depending on location and the type of data center. Colocation data centers, where businesses rent space to house servers, had more impact on prices than hyperscale data centers for single tenants. That may be both because hyperscalers have tended to build in more rural areas where there was more room on the grid, and because hyperscalers have also been more likely to sign contracts where they cover the cost of adding new infrastructure—sometimes new wind and solar power that can replace more expensive gas generation.

The risks of a grid stretched to its limits

That doesn’t mean the effect on energy bills will be small going forward. Another new report from a nonprofit called ESIG, the Energy Systems Integration Group, looks at multiple factors that influence what could happen because of a hypothetical new data center. First, in theory, there still might be some places where there’s enough extra power infrastructure on the grid that a data center might lower costs. The report’s modeling suggests that scenario could lower rates by 0.88 cents per kilowatt hour in the example of a hypothetical utility in the Southeast. But because of the scale of demand for electricity, if those places exist, they probably won’t for long. And a grid might need that extra capacity for other new uses, too.

Several factors could push bills higher. A data center might overestimate how much electricity it needs, so new energy infrastructure gets built and other ratepayers get stuck helping cover the bill. A data center might be built late or shut down earlier than expected, again leaving other ratepayers covering the cost of new infrastructure. In some regions, utilities don’t own all of their own power plants and have to buy energy in auctions; as data centers sharply increase demand, wholesale prices go up, and that gets passed on to customers.

The type of power plants that are being built to support data centers can also affect costs for consumers. Energy Innovation, an organization focused on clean energy, has estimated that relying on fossil fuels for new energy generation would add $29.7 billion a year to customer bills by 2030; clean energy could save around $5 billion a year. If coal and gas prices spike, as they have in recent years, the cost could jump to $40.5 billion a year. In that case, clean energy could save as much as $13.5 billion.

In a worst-case scenario where multiple factors are simultaneously pushing electric rates higher, the ESIG report estimates that it could raise rates by 1.32 cents per kilowatt-hour. (It doesn’t translate that into monthly bills, but that might mean paying roughly $10 more a month.)

[Image: ESIG] Who pays for all that power?

Other factors could mitigate rate increases. States and utilities are beginning to require contracts with minimum billing terms, so data centers wouldn’t end up paying less if they happen to use less energy. Other contracts include early termination fees. Data centers or their customers can also cover the cost of new power plants. If federal regulations change, it could also be easier to charge data centers for upgrades to transmission networks.

The terms of these contracts are evolving rapidly. “What’s happening is actually quite remarkable [in terms of] how quickly things are changing,” says Trieu Mai, senior director of programs and research at ESIG. More than a dozen states, from Tennessee to Minnesota, have passed laws designed to protect consumers from rising energy bills. Hundreds of data center bills were filed this year. In some states, attorneys general are also challenging data center contracts that they say don’t adequately protect consumers.

Utilities are also changing their approach, though the details differ everywhere. In North Carolina, where Duke Energy has said that data centers are responsible for more than 85% of load growth on the local grid, the utility initially planned to raise rates 18% next year (the cost also included upgrades like making infrastructure more resilient in storms). Under pressure from the governor, that was negotiated down to around 9.5%. Now, the utility has proposed a new tariff for large customers like data centers, though it won’t apply to contracts signed before July 2026, and critics say that it doesn’t go far enough—it doesn’t cover the cost of new transmission upgrades, for example, or what might happen if a data center leaves early.

These changes represent a major shift in how utilities typically operate, and they may not happen everywhere. “Utilities are spending billions of dollars on new infrastructure for data centers, and the basic utility business model is to spread the cost of new infrastructure to everyone,” says Ari Peskoe, director of the Electricity Law Initiative at the Harvard Law School Environmental and Energy Law Program.

Even when companies claim they’ll cover the cost of new grid infrastructure, it’s difficult to verify whether that’s actually happening. “It’s very hard because a lot of the details are confidential,” says Peskoe. “And then there’s not a lot of transparency about what’s actually being built for data centers, particularly when it comes to the high-capacity transmission network, interstate transmission system that connects everyone together. Utilities are not really doing a good job of disclosing what is being built for what data center. The federal regulator is ordering more transparency, but that’s still a process. So TBD on how that all plays out.”

The bottom line: Transparency is critical if residents want to understand what a proposed data center could mean for their utility bills. And at a time when data centers have become a defining issue in the midterm elections—and most Americans are convinced that data centers will significantly spike bills—there’s no simple answer to what impact a large data center might actually have. “The answer would be: it depends,” says Mai. “Of course, it’s an unsatisfying answer. That’s why you have to do the math to see what it depends on for your region.”

AI agents have no rules, so Meta wrote its own

3 weeks 2 days ago

Why would anyone trust Meta?

After all, this is the company that became the world’s avatar for shameless and exploitative data harvesting. The same data mastery that powers one of the most effective advertising platforms ever made also gave us Cambridge Analytica, whistleblowers like Frances Haugen and Sarah Wynn-Williams, and unflattering films like The Social Dilemma and, just this month, The Social Reckoning. In the Axios-Harris Poll 100, Meta scored a lowly 59.6, down in the basement with ByteDance and X.

Publishers have their own reasons to be suspicious. Meta once vastly increased the reach of its properties, and even paid them for content, then abruptly took it all away when its priorities shifted. Meta has blocked news entirely in Canada since 2023, and briefly did the same in Australia in 2021.

So when Nieman Lab reported that Meta had changed its terms of service in a way that seemed to give itself permission to scrape the site of any company with a Meta Business account, nobody was inclined to give it the benefit of the doubt.

The new terms, which allow Meta to use automated tools to “access, index, cache, analyze, collect, retrieve, or crawl” websites “associated with” a business account, and to use that content to “provide, develop, improve, research, train” Meta products, could be interpreted as signing over to Meta the license to do whatever it wants with your content, including training its AI models or even offering up AI answers based on it. Indeed, three legal experts Nieman Lab consulted warned publishers of exactly that danger.

{"blockType":"mv-promo-block","data":{"imageDesktopUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2025\/03\/media-copilot.png","imageMobileUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2025\/03\/fe289316-bc4f-44ef-96bf-148b3d8578c1_1440x1440.png","eyebrow":"","headline":"\u003Cstrong\u003ESubscribe to \u003Cem\u003EThe Media Copilot\u003C\/em\u003E\u003C\/strong\u003E","dek":"Want more about how AI is changing media? Never miss an update from Pete Pachal by signing up for \u003Cem\u003EThe Media Copilot\u003C\/em\u003E. To learn more, visit \u003Ca href=\u0022https:\/\/mediacopilot.substack.com\/\u0022\u003Emediacopilot.substack.com\u003C\/a\u003E","subhed":"","description":"","ctaText":"SIGN UP","ctaUrl":"https:\/\/mediacopilot.substack.com\/","theme":{"bg":"#f5f5f5","text":"#000000","eyebrow":"#9aa2aa","subhed":"#ffffff","buttonBg":"#000000","buttonHoverBg":"#3b3f46","buttonText":"#ffffff"},"imageDesktopId":91453847,"imageMobileId":91453848,"shareable":false,"slug":"","wpCssClasses":""}}

Meta quickly backpedaled, sort of. Within a day, it removed the word train and limited scraped content to its advertising and business products. A spokesperson insisted, “This is not about scraping news sites.” That didn’t calm anyone down. Legal experts said the revised language still permits mass scraping, and publisher groups on both sides of the Atlantic demanded a pause and filed complaints with regulators. This week Meta pushed the effective date from October 30 to November 20. The U.K.’s News Media Association called the delay “a pause, not a solution.”

What Meta probably wants

It’s unlikely that Meta secretly changed its position on what has been, for the past three years, the single most important legal issue in how AI affects media, and then tried to bury it in a terms-of-service update. The impetus for the change was likely more mundane: Meta says the crawling language came from folding its Ad Creative Generative AI Terms into its main commercial terms, and AI tools that build ads for a business presumably need to read that business’s website. As Meta pushes further into agents like its Muse assistant, its bots will need to touch the open web more, not less.

But you don’t have to be a conspiracy theorist to see how Meta stepped in it here. The change isn’t irrelevant, and publishers should be concerned about how legal agreements are worded. And some of Meta’s wording is hard to explain away. The terms let Meta create “test credentials,” which Cornell law professor James Grimmelmann said would let it sign up as a fake user to get past registration walls.

There’s no opt-out short of abandoning Meta’s business tools. And the change arrived just as Meta began charging some accounts, through its new Meta One subscription, to post links to the same content its bots could crawl for free. And, as I said, Meta has wholly earned its reputation for not considering all the dimensions of how its actions can lead to disastrous consequences.

What Meta did here, and the media’s understandable reaction, is a symptom of a deeper problem. Some will blame AI companies’ thirst for data, or a Machiavellian quest to squeeze the media industry, but the real issue is a vacuum of standards and rules around what AI agents, and the crawlers that power them, can and cannot do.

Whoever holds the leverage writes the law

You can see this same issue in another freakout from the past week: an Axios report that banks were seeing a growing number of “unauthorized” AI agents accessing customer accounts. While that sounds scary out of context, what it mostly represents is individuals using AI services to access their accounts and take actions on their behalf, not some kind of mass hacking event.

Still, there are real concerns around agents the bank didn’t sanction accessing customer accounts, not the least of which is liability when something (inevitably) goes wrong. That’s why JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon told analysts earlier this month that letting in outside agents is “just too risky for clients and for JPMorgan,” and the bank now blocks them from logging in. Schwab is doing the same while steering clients to its own AI assistant (a move that also happens to protect its lucrative cash business), and Citi doesn’t allow third-party agents to log in either. One of the agents getting locked out, incidentally, is Meta’s own Muse.

In both cases, the platform saw either an opportunity or a gap with respect to AI usage, and as the party with leverage, it decided the rules. Which is exactly what happens when there are no rules—the person with the biggest gun gets to make them. When it comes to AI, and especially agents, we’re all living in Tombstone.

We saw the same dynamic in last year’s dustup between Perplexity and Cloudflare. To recap, Cloudflare accused Perplexity of using stealth crawlers to get around sites’ bot-blocking preferences, and Perplexity insisted its agents were legitimate proxies for actual users, entitled to the same access.

Regardless of who you think is right, it’s clear Perplexity had leverage when it was them versus individual sites. But when Cloudflare got involved, the equation changed. As the gatekeeper for a huge share of the web, Cloudflare delisted Perplexity as a verified bot and gave every customer a way to block its stealth crawlers. Perplexity has since deputized itself in another matter, blocking ads that Time served to AI agents as “deceptive” without saying how it defines the term.

Who gets to be sheriff?

Certainly, the system would benefit from common rules and standards, and—to stretch the Wild West analogy—we’re beginning to see the townspeople band together. Collective organizations like SPUR (the Standards for Publisher Usage Rights coalition), now more than 80 publishers strong, are looking to establish standards for how publisher content is tracked and valued when AI systems use it.

And lawmakers are moving, too: The bipartisan Stealth Bot Prohibition Act in Congress would require crawlers to identify themselves and their purpose. And several states, including New York, have already passed their own versions, so any site that crawlers scrape—not just publishers—will have a better idea of what to do with them.

What this means for Meta and anyone else attempting to use their leverage to set the rules: You overreach at your peril. While legal departments will always default to grabbing the widest possible set of rights, that will arouse suspicion and mistrust in a world with no rules to govern those rights, and it’s why it’s not enough for a Meta spokesperson to simply say publishers can still block its crawler with robots.txt. Putting those words in the actual terms of service, as WAN-IFRA, the global publishers’ association, has demanded, would make clear to everyone what rules you think you’re playing under.

The fact that those rules are up to Meta at all is the real vacuum. Right now, whoever holds the leverage decides what an agent can do with what it collects: Meta through its terms, JPMorgan through its login page, Perplexity through its index. A three-week delay doesn’t change that. Until someone builds a framework everyone has to follow, you can’t blame publishers for circling the wagons whenever someone pins on a badge and declares themselves the new sheriff in town.

{"blockType":"mv-promo-block","data":{"imageDesktopUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2025\/03\/media-copilot.png","imageMobileUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2025\/03\/fe289316-bc4f-44ef-96bf-148b3d8578c1_1440x1440.png","eyebrow":"","headline":"\u003Cstrong\u003ESubscribe to \u003Cem\u003EThe Media Copilot\u003C\/em\u003E\u003C\/strong\u003E","dek":"Want more about how AI is changing media? Never miss an update from Pete Pachal by signing up for \u003Cem\u003EThe Media Copilot\u003C\/em\u003E. To learn more, visit \u003Ca href=\u0022https:\/\/mediacopilot.substack.com\/\u0022\u003Emediacopilot.substack.com\u003C\/a\u003E","subhed":"","description":"","ctaText":"SIGN UP","ctaUrl":"https:\/\/mediacopilot.substack.com\/","theme":{"bg":"#f5f5f5","text":"#000000","eyebrow":"#9aa2aa","subhed":"#ffffff","buttonBg":"#000000","buttonHoverBg":"#3b3f46","buttonText":"#ffffff"},"imageDesktopId":91453847,"imageMobileId":91453848,"shareable":false,"slug":"","wpCssClasses":""}}

4 steps for running a panel people actually want to attend

3 weeks 2 days ago

Suppose you are called upon to organize a panel discussion. The task may look easy. But if you’re not careful, you might end up overseeing a boring multispeaker event or a free-for-all where panelists interrupt each other and talk at cross-purposes.

It is up to you to make this format work and create a coherent, engaging session. But how? Follow the steps below and you’ll bring order to the panel, inspire listeners, and create an exciting event.

1. Choose Speakers

Your first task is to select the speakers. Choose people who are knowledgeable and bring different perspectives.

Suppose your topic is “AI in our company.” You might select panelists who show how artificial intelligence is being used creatively in a variety of disciplines in the company. One speaker might discuss how AI is improving the hiring process. Another might discuss how AI is helping leaders. To make things interesting, include a naysayer, someone who says AI is a hazard to achieving the company’s goals.

2. Brief the Speakers

Let the presenters know why they’ve been chosen and  what they should focus on. Tell them who the other speakers are and what perspective they might bring.

Suppose the topic is “What Makes a Good Leader.” Suggest that each speaker focuses on a quality they feel is critical to effective leadership, such as charisma or emotional intelligence. Make sure your request is a good fit for each of them.

Tell presenters how long they will have to speak and if there will be an audience Q&A. That will allow them to prepare appropriate talking points. Make clear that the time limits are more than suggestions. They are needed so the event goes smoothly.

3. Moderate the Event

Your role will likely include moderating the event.

Open the session with a brief overview of the topic, its importance, and the range of perspectives that will be covered. Your opening will help listeners better understand the discussion—and why this panel is important.

Introduce each speaker. It’s best to do this when that individual is about to present, rather than introducing everyone at the start. In your introductions you can suggest how a person’s presentation relates to the larger themes. That underscores the coherence of the overall panel. You want to avoid the disaster of disconnected speeches.

When the last speaker has concluded and you have thanked all the panelists and provided a brief summary, invite questions from the audience if the format of your event permits. This is an exciting part of the event, so save plenty of time for Q&A.

It is likely that the questions will be targeted to particular speakers. If not, you choose the best candidate to answer that question.

Always prepare some questions yourself. That’s particularly useful if there are few from the audience or if you feel an important area has been neglected.

Throughout the panel discussion keep the tone enjoyable. The best events are lively and full of fun and laughter.

4. Conclude the Event

Conclude by summing up what the audience can take away from the panel and what the overall message is.

Thank the audience for coming and conclude with a call to action that suggests how the audience can act upon the knowledge it has gained.

Brick has become essential for reducing screen time during the day. Its new device will curb your pre-bed scroll

3 weeks 2 days ago

Since it launched in September 2023, Brick—the NFC-enabled productivity tool that lets users tap their phone to block a set list of apps—has become a popular way to get people to limit their screen time. Now the company wants to bring the simplicity of its flagship product into the bedroom to help people get a good night’s sleep sans smartphone.

Brick Night, launched October 22, is only the second product from Brick, and it’s designed to make cutting out smartphone distraction effortless—removing the need to tap your phone at all.

“After years of using Brick and talking with the people who use it, we’ve seen that boundaries work best when they’re built into your life,” Brick cofounder TJ Driver tells Fast Company. “A natural next step was protecting physical spaces, so Brick Night builds on that foundation by automatically blocking distracting apps when you’re in your set space.”

Brick Night uses Bluetooth to block apps on a phone when the user enters their bedroom—or whatever room they want to be distraction-free.

[Photo: Brick]

To set up, users choose a list of apps to be blocked and set a duration for the block. Then, once Brick Night detects their phone nearby, those apps become inaccessible for the chosen amount of time.

While the device can automatically lock apps in any room of a user’s choosing, for Driver, focusing on the bedroom was “the clear place to start.”

The new device tackles a growing set of issues stemming from phone use at night. Studies have found that around 87% of Americans sleep with their phones in the bedroom, a habit that can significantly affect sleep quality. Researchers have found that just one hour of phone use in bed can increase the risk of insomnia by 59%.

Brick Night is responding to a desire from users to cut back on that phone time. In a Pew Research study released in September, 45% of adults surveyed said they’ve tried to reduce their smartphone use in the past year, including 58% of people younger than 50. Some 41% said their smartphone use affects the amount of sleep they get.

“Our phones do have real uses in the bedroom, like alarms, important calls, and audio to wind down, but they also pull us into work, scrolling, and notifications. Brick Night builds the boundary into the room itself, ” Driver says. “You keep what you need, and you stick to a distraction-free routine every night without having to remember anything.”

The new device, which is slightly larger than the original Brick and comes in a midnight blue color, will support multiple users and can cover a space as large as 25 by 25 feet. It sells for $129 on the official Brick website.

Wendy’s store closures: Franchisee could close another 60 locations in Chapter 11 bankruptcy

3 weeks 3 days ago

One of Wendy’s biggest franchisees is moving to potentially close as many as 60 restaurants, adding to the dozens of stores it has already closed this year.

The move comes after the franchisee, Meritage Hospitality Group, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Western District of Michigan on September 17, 2026. At the time of its September bankruptcy filing, Meritage operated 314 Wendy’s locations.

Michigan-based Meritage is seeking approval to close at least 20 (but no more than 60) stores, with potential closures to take place over the coming weeks through November 13. 

Which Wendy’s restaurants will close?

The latest filing doesn’t name specific locations. It notes that specific closings will be determined and disclosed later.

As Fast Company previously reported, Meritage has already closed 33 underperforming stores since filing for bankruptcy last month. The closures across nine states were required by the company’s lenders as a condition for Meritage to continue using cash during the bankruptcy process. 

In addition, the franchisee had shuttered around 60 underperforming stores before its September bankruptcy filing. Those closures began in Q4 2025.

If approved, the additional store closures could mean that Meritage would lose nearly a third of the 314 locations that it had operated at the time of its bankruptcy petition.

Fast Company reached out to Wendy’s and Meritage Hospitality Group for more information. We’ll update this story if we receive a reply.

Entrepreneurship might be the key to a longer life

3 weeks 3 days ago

If you thought entrepreneurship was too stressful a path to venture down, you might want to reassess. A new study found that there may be a surprising benefit to starting a business: longevity. 

The study, titled “Do Entrepreneurs Live Longer?,” comes from researchers at the School of Business at Stevens Institute of Technology in New Jersey and was published in the Journal of Business on October 22. For the research, associate professor Cristiano Bellavitis and his collaborators examined 20 years of data from 27,501 Americans 50 and older.

Interestingly, it found that those who work for themselves may live longer than those who spend the bulk of their lives working for others: Entrepreneurs had a 10% lower risk of premature death. That was true even after researchers accounted for other factors that might tip the scale in either direction, such as age, income and wealth, and level of education.

The research offers a different perspective on work that can feel all-encompassing or lead to longer hours, which entrepreneurship is often associated with. While previous studies have found that long hours can lead to an uptick in death by heart-related illness, such as stroke, other considerations apparently come into play, such as the sense of freedom that can (sometimes) flow from working for yourself. 

Bellavitis said it’s a vital component that showed up in the study. “Most people think of entrepreneurship as extremely stressful, and it certainly can be. But entrepreneurship also gives people a high degree of autonomy and the opportunity to pursue something they genuinely love or care about,” he stated in a press release. “Our findings suggest those benefits may have lasting effects.”

Entrepreneurs are known to experience burnout in high numbers. However, the study revealed there was one major consideration that made the difference: The greatest advantage happened when that autonomy was the most present. “What seems to matter is not entrepreneurship alone, but the circumstances under which people enter it,” Bellavitis says. 

For example, when entrepreneurs launched businesses out of desire rather than necessity, longevity showed up. That means that, no matter what your profession—and whether you’re working for yourself or someone else—choice seems to matter deeply.

Longevity might be the biggest payout, but it wasn’t the only one the study spotted. Entrepreneurs reported lower levels of both depression and loneliness. While those are two mental health factors that can contribute to better health, they can also contribute to a greater sense of happiness. 

Therefore, entrepreneurship—at least when pursued out of passion and purpose rather than need—might not just be the key to a long life, but also a happy one.

Why Marissa Mayer’s AI parenting anecdote received such a strong reaction on social media

3 weeks 3 days ago

Many people use AI for routine tasks like drafting emails or answering quick questions. But former Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer used it for something that social media users aren’t necessarily thrilled about.

In a New York Times interview published over the weekend, Mayer revealed that when tasked with coming up with three bullet points to summarize what made her 10-year-old daughter special, she asked AI for help.

“It came back and was, like, your daughter is empathetic, creative, and an animal lover,” Mayer told the news outlet.

Mayer served as Yahoo’s CEO from 2012 to 2017 and was Google’s first female engineer. She now runs an AI startup called Dazzle, which launched in September after raising $8 million in seed funding last year.

“This is so bleak”

To source the bullet points, Mayer used Dazzle AI, an AI personal assistant that relies on one’s camera roll rather than on text.

While Mayer allegedly found the response perfect, users on social media are thinking otherwise, with most pointing out the bizarre or disappointing nature of offloading human emotions and parenting to an agent.

“This is so bleak,” political commentator Keith Edwards wrote on X, in a post with 1.9 million views and hundreds of comments.

Many were quick to speculate about the veracity of the anecdote, hoping it could have been an embellishment or completely made up as a way for Mayer to promote her new product.

“I hope this is an exaggeration to make for an interesting click-baity article,” one user said on X. Another added: “The best-case scenario is that this is a lie made up for the article.”

Others were simply confused at the need to turn to artificial intelligence for a simple task like providing three bullet points about a loved one.

One user wrote: “That’s the type of thing we expect elementary school children to be able to come up with on the fly.”

The idea of outsourcing tender parenting moments to AI has proved controversial for a while now. Two years ago, Google (where Mayer once worked) received backlash over a commercial that depicted a father using the tech to write a fan letter for his daughter. Google ultimately pulled the ad.

The continued discourse around Mayer’s anecdote on social media has since caught the attention of Mayer herself, who published a response to the backlash on X.

“To be clear, I didn’t use Dazzle because I was overwhelmed by making a slide. I used it because summing up your child in a few bullets feels laughably limiting. And, since our team had just gotten an early prototype running, I wanted to see what deeper threads it might find,” she shared on X.

Reached for comment, a Dazzle spokesperson referred Fast Company to Mayer’s post on X.

The post further explained how Mayer used Dazzle, which surfaced “forgotten kindergarten projects,” connected them with “who [her daughter] is today,” and informed the final project.

If nothing else, the anecdote and response have sparked a debate about what we risk losing when we turn over our thinking to machines.

“Bleak doesn’t begin to describe this,” one user wrote on X. “The future of our civilization depends on our continued ability to use our own brains, at least a little bit.”

Checked
8 minutes 12 seconds ago
Fast Company
Fast Company inspires a new breed of innovative and creative thought leaders who are actively inventing the future of business.
Subscribe to Fast Company feed